After passing through the horrible fire of battling Amendment One here in North Carolina, I felt drained, not just because of the results, but the battle on this front and many others shows just how far we have to go in addressing society’s myriad problems with racism, homophobia, transphobia, classism, misogyny, etc.
It makes me sad and weary. If only we could harness all of the energy put into hate- and fear-based thoughts and actions and turn it into positive action for everyone’s benefit.
I don’t know how full-time activists do it; my online and offline activism has to be fit in between a day job and the rest of my crazy life, so I always feel I can do more, even as my health fails me. I’ve never been part of the LGBT establishment, never held a movement job, or had access to — or actual — power, so anything I’ve accomplished is just by using my voice through writing and engaging with people in virtual and real space as an accidental activist.
I just want to leave this earth with some sense that it’s in a better place than when I was brought into it. Maybe that’s foolish and hopeless; I don’t know if I have any impact at all, really. For all the gains in human rights we’ve made in this country since I was born in 1963, sometimes I wonder where we are heading, where do we really want to go as a society.
It always comes back to a question — why do so many of our fellow human beings spend so much time and energy in the pursuit of demeaning and devaluing people, gleefully earning paychecks to strategize how to take away, abuse or deny civil rights of fellow human beings? What is wrong with people? Is everything related to treating one another as equals too difficult a concept to address?
The answer is of course it is; there’s always a game of one ups-manship, of protecting privilege and wealth through denial and manipulation, with fear the most essential ingredient feeding the discrimination and bigotry. The masses fall for fear almost every single time. We’re so much more comfortable at making snap judgments about anyone different from ourselves in an attempt to feel superior, to gain an edge of some kind. I’ve seen way too many petulant adults behave more like children when their sense of entitlement is threatened by nothing more than their lack of understanding. When paired with a lack of any intellectual curiosity, you get a real winner.
Of course to move past these barriers, a person has to have some sense of self-reflection, the ability to see (and admit and address) their own flaws. For instance, in the laundry list of “isms” I mentioned at the top, I need to add ableism, based on my own observations (and unexplored biases) as I’ve become increasingly disabled because of rheumatoid arthritis. Able-bodied people don’t know how lucky they are in basic navigation in society (I definitely took it for granted). You don’t know what you have until it is gone. Example: when I went to the Protect NC campaign HQ to report on Amendment One on election day, there was no elevator, just stairs (and I had a rolling bag to carry my laptop). I was SOL. Even worse, when I moved over to the Equality NC HQ, again, no elevator and flights of stairs to climb. Folks bounded up thinking nothing of doing it (which in years past, wouldn’t have fazed me either). We often “other” the disabled. And yes, for most of us it’s hard to think about walking in someone else’s shoes until they are your shoes.
For amazing insight on this, I recommend reading activist David Mixner’s ”Hell’s Kitchen Journal: My View From A Wheelchair.” He chronicles how differently he was treated by people he knew well while he was temporarily confined to a wheelchair.
What an eye opener for me concerning some of the challenges people face in wheel chairs. I knew most of these people and that made it even more disappointing. They weren’t about to move and lose their spot except that all they had to do was take a few steps backward. There were some other observations I noticed. When I was without the wheelchair, people would come up and chat and engage in conversation. When I was in the wheel chair few would engage and many felt uncomfortable. People would nod or wave at me across the hall but few approached. Nothing had changed about me except my position.
And these are people without hostile intent. Our brains are clearly wired to feel uncomfortable about others in situations/conditions that we don’t identify with. Knowing that, shouldn’t we know better than to fall prey to our default reactions? As (allegedly) advanced members of the animal kingdom, are we reduced to excusing natural impulses of fear/difference to “I can’t help it?” Please.
I think sometimes we’re just lazy in the end. Some of us will never question ourselves when we have a fear reaction, without direct evidence to support it, someone approaching us who is black or brown (hoodie or not), or why some men feel uncomfortable working for a woman in the supervisory position reflexively, or why some people somehow feel the value of their marriage is in jeopardy because two men or two women down the street want the right to marry, or any other judgment call of that nature. We’re not prisoners to these feelings, yet we see people ruled by them, stoked by others to respond to them.
When will the madness stop? Probably never.
/rant




26 Comments


Hey — hang in there. You did/are doing awesome work. Things are changing and faster now.
Pam! There’s so much progress and you’re part of it.
I never thought I’d see this much progress toward gay equality in my lifetime and people out there speaking up like you are why. I, like many, just accepted that i was gonna be “less of a person” as far as society is concerned. Now, that perception is gone. But, I agree, changes aren’t coming fast enough. MLK said it best in the letter from the birmingham jail: “For years now I have heard the word “Wait!” It rings in the ear of every Negro with piercing familiarity. This “Wait” has almost always meant “Never.” We must come to see, with one of our distinguished jurists, that “justice too long delayed is justice denied.”
There are a lot of mean-spirited people out there who feel better about themselves when they can down other people, but the things they can get away with are dwindling. Good riddance! When LGBT people have equal rights, it’ll be good for everyone. The last major area of government-sponsored inequality will have fallen. Then we can all feel real good.
Pam, beautifully, heartfully stated. You do good work….you move us all forward. Never.Give.Up. (thanks, Southerndragon.) I remember when my ex was trying to move women forward in the manufacturing world and getting nasty pushback. I told him that the men on the line would rather work for a black supervisor than a woman supervisor. He didn’t believe me. I said, “Go ask them.” He did. And he learned. My marriage didn’t survive, but I still respect that my ex kept on pushing.
You, Pam, bring something to this push. Keep on keeping on. We are behind and around you. Never.Give.Up.
Pam.
This post reminds me of Susan Anthony and Elizabeth Stanton’s letters to each other .. specifically 1) one of Anthony’s where she confesses absolute weariness and a desire for simple domestic comforts and somebody beside her at night .. and 2) a deeply moving one from Stanton, much later in both their lives, sort of a summation and personal celebration .. “It is fifty-one years since we first met and we have been busy through every one of them, stirring up the world to reorganize the rights of women … We little dreamed when we began this contest … that half a century later we would be compelled to leave the finish of the battle to another generation of women. But our hearts are filled with joy to know that they enter upon this task equipped with a college education, with business experience, with the freely admitted right to speak in public — all of which were denied to women fifty years ago.”
You’re the best, Pam. Thank you equally for your activism and your personal honesty.
It is frustrating. Often what seems so rational, logical, compassionate, and obvious somehow seems so ‘foreign’ and threatening to many.
I think the underlying battle is really between tradition vs. secularism.
Different ‘minded’ people subscribe to both the former and latter. But as time moves forward, and generations pass, I see secularists multiplying in numbers (slowly but surely) and those bounded by tradition, becoming more and more a minority — ‘Taliban’, if you will.
Great diary!
“The masses fail for fear…”
Okay…but why is Barack Obama failing?
If you get tired, take a break. that’s the very best thing I can think of.
Usually, when I am pushing, I can’t see anything except my desire; it may be a imperative desire, but it doesn’t allow life to step in and show me the way.
It’s easy to get discouraged these days.
I think of Jackson Brown’s song “Running on Empty”
Esp the lines ” I look around for the friends I used to turn to to pull me through, looking into their eyes, I see they’re running too”.
Life is difficult and always has been. I think the trick is to allow ourselves to see the wonder that is still here.
It’s the way I stay more or less sane
Pam;
You do good works and the world is a better place because you’re in it. I just got off the phone with a friend of mine and we were talking about how just 100 years ago women couldn’t vote and black men were 3/5s of a person. Things have come a long way since 1912 indeed. That isn’t to say that any of us should be satisfied with that or that Progressives in general should take a break from pushing for a better, fairer and more just world. Things could always be better and change is never easy or without setbacks. The history of this nation is clear: there is a slow drift to the right, followed by a rapid snap back to the left so change will come. Eventually. What comforts me is the knowledge that progressives always win in the end. Because if the capacity for change was perfectly balanced with the fear of it, we’d still be picking fleas off one another in caves somewhere. I know how discouraging it can be and these days the hate is undisguised. Take some time to regroup if you need to girl. You deserve it.
Righteous rant btw.
I know how tired you must be…here’s a ‘toon, to make you feel better:
http://news.yahoo.com/photos/tony-auth-slideshow/20120510-ta120510-gif-photo-200813273.html
Hang in there, Pam! You are fighting the good fight and making a difference. We cannot win every battle, but we are winning the war, however slowly. There will always be setbacks and we can never relax our vigilance, but the world is a very much better place than it was when I was growing up in Oklahoma in the 50s and 60s. We get a little closer everyday to Martin Luther King’s dream that the day will come when we are all judged by the content of our character and not by the color of our skin, our gender, our sexual orientation, or any of the thousand other things some people would persecute others for. I have been fighting that battle for more than 40 years and never expect to stop fighting it, but we are making the world a better, and more decent place.
And, Pam, it seems that it is the old white guys and gals (not, of course, those you encounter here at the divine and liberal Lake) who are causing most of the problems. I look at the lives my kids are living and the friends they have and the people they work with….it is different and fresh and exciting and…….in time, they will be the leaders of this mess of a country.
And I’m sorry, Pam, that more of the hard core FDLers haven’t yet arrived, so just let me give you {{{{hugs}}}}}} from us. Write on!
Pam, I just love that Madonna and Child photo!
Pam, I too want to support you in taking a deep breath, honoring your work, and holding you up.
These are tough times, and when the battle is personal, it is very hard to face the immediate defeat. Things are moving forward, and in this struggle, the young are very far ahead of all the elders who are stuck on this issue. The old are dying, the young will carry this day in the end.
So for now we have to be patient, we have to be thankful that the battle is supported by many, and you are not alone.
Don’t give up, keep up the fight. Civil rights will come for all someday, and it is not so far now. In solidarity! bg
I think you do great work. Thank you!
No, Pam… you’ve supplanted it! I swear, Pam, you’re a fresh of breath air. My friends and I used to scream at stupid decisions made by groups like the HRC, and their obsession over the cocktail parties over fighting for our rights.
Not only did it feel like there was nothing we could do about it… but it felt like there was no one to even talk to outside of the HRC ‘we have to be nice to people discriminating against it’ mindset. People like you have helped give a space for us to do that in — and people like you have helped force those groups to be ‘fiercer advocates’ in our civil rights, including the rights of the LB and T in GLBT.
Note: Someone on FB said “I tend not to question why people are hateful. It actually doesn’t help me and experience as taught me that too much questioning of other peoples motives can only burn me out.”
My problem (or is it even a problem) is that I’m just curious about human nature and how we do/don’t challenge “what comes naturally” when it comes to understanding, accepting and affirming that difference is not a threat. The current politics in this country seem to bring out in the worst in people, who are willingly showing their fear as aggressive hatred of difference.
I wrote the piece in the “thinking out loud” vein. I’m not looking for kudos or anything (so many others do so much more), but thank you all for the kind comments of support), I just wanted to express what I am feeling, something I do rarely on the blog any more, but did a lot back in the early days (2004).
I just feel like I am running out of time; I think the last two years of watching my body breakdown prematurely because of the myriad neurological/auto-immune disorders (the severity of which is nastily affected by weather/barometric changes) has taken away my ability to do more, to be confident about what I can do.
I am reminded about that when I think of how often I have to say no now to speak to groups, go to panels to share what I know, conferences I used to enjoy traveling to, meeting and speaking to people in states where it is tougher than I have it here. It sucks.
The horrid truth is the proponents of hate seem to have boundless energy (and money), because they are driven by fear of change and the knowledge that they are on the losing side of history. Their goal is to make as many people on the side of progressive change as miserable as they can while the bigots go down in flames.
That said, I often find myself equally frustrated by allies of all sorts, ones who don’t have to live in the worlds of demographic intersectionality that I do, often oblivious to the frustration of being attacked on all sides — racial bias in the LGBT community, heterosupremacy in the straight community, misogyny, regional bias (people, please stop telling me to move!). It’s less hostility than profound ignorance that still needs to be addressed with purported allies that is soul-draining.
As I noted, NC and Amendment One was just an acute example of the perfect storm of BS. The fact that we know it could have been defeated if 1) voters knew the full harms (most North Carolinians supported some form of legal recognition for same-sex couples) and 2) they came out to vote. Neither happened.
But that’s a frustration that you all know about on a host of issues — the electorate at large has been put to sleep, content to go about their business and watch or read little news, sit in front of the idiot box watching the latest reality show, and never attend a city council meeting, write a letter to the editor, and don’t know any local or state officials in races on the ballot.
And then out of those who do bother to show up at the polls, so many are low-info voters who base their vote on the most clever (or fear-inducing) 30-second commercial.
It’s pretty depressing when you think about it, but even with all of that, we are still winning in the long run. I have to believe that. Otherwise, yes, I would give up. I’m glad so many are in this to win it, it’s just that most of the money and power structure is behind the status quo.
I do have to say it’s tempting to return to anonymity and check out of the political process like the uninformed, unmotivated masses and just live my life again. The problem is that political engagement/social justice is in my family’s DNA, and I don’t think I can just shut it off.
I enjoy and appreciate the posts of optimism made here, but feel much the same as Pam. I was born in 1961, so in my life the forces of hate have mostly won the battles. The killing of JFK, MLK, RFK, Malcolm X all represent victories for the bad guys (for the most part). Maybe I’m too romantic where these men were concerned, but it FEELS like more progress would have been made had RFK been elected president instead of Nixon; who, on the other hand, seems like a great guy when compared to the current crop of Republicans.
I’ve heard it said that in the long run, Americans tend to get it right, but it is hard to get more wrong than Americans protesting neighbors in need that might possibly get healthcare in the summer of 2009. It is an image that is hard to shake.
Pam, thanks for your heart-felt post.
It seems to me that the psychological progression for those who oppose anyone “different” goes something like: guilt, fear, projection, anger, attack. Fighting back seems like the response they want and expect. This justifies their original fears. Perversely, I think the only real solution involves helping the guilt and fear-ridden to feel better about themselves. And even as I type this I realize the huge difficulty of the path I’m suggesting. But revenge or counter-attack seems like a very unproductive path.
And at the risk of sounding too cynical or smarmy, I have a friend who is fond of saying, “I don’t expect anything from anybody, and I still get disappointed.”
Pam, my sense is that you could start collecting the differences, one by one, you’ve made in individual lives and never live long enough to finish. I still recall your response to an issue on bisexuality some time back that was so right on. You may have no idea how unique that is.
Sometimes I really believe we are the least understood population in LGBT. Even the transgender experience enjoys more understanding in the general population, even if the most victimized. Not only is bi the least understood, but the most distrusted by all, including the others of LGBT. If people don’t just throw us into the category of G/L for having had an intimate same-sex experience, they throw you into “untrustworthy” believing you cannot be “fulfilled” by anyone else by reason of nature’s gender specificity.
Just because you fully enjoy intimacy with either gender does not mean you cannot be committed to, and completed by, one person of one gender, any more or less than anyone else. And betrayal, too, is no more or less characteristic than anyone else.
Even I did not fully understand for most of my life. I’m 70 y.o. and “bi” has not been around for more than a generation. (When AIDS broke out and response was debated, the common wisdom was that bi-sexuals could be discounted because we were “statistically insignificant” or “aberrations”.) Through my adolescence and young adulthood, I was just referred to as “over-sexed” and I accepted that. Some kind of sexual freak. So it has taken a whole lifetime to understand myself and the population I belong to. I’m grateful to arrive at a point where I even feel blessed and more fortunate than non-bi people.
For one individual, I thank you.
You’ve made a huge difference, Pam. You have been a daily must-read for me for a couple of years now, and I often forward your posts to friends and family because you make your case in such an honest and elegant way.
I can’t imagine what you’re feeling in the wake of that awful vote in NC. I remember feeling heartbroken after Prop. 8 won in California, and I live in a state (Massachusetts) where my marriage is entitled to legal protection.
I wish I could offer you more than a “hang in there,” but I can’t. All I can say is that your voice is a prominent and important one in our struggle, and I thank you for that.
To put it in military terms, Pam, you’ve just completed a front-line combat tour, so of course, you’re experiencing burnout. Hang back a little (but only for a little while, please), spend some quality time with Kate, and enjoy life.
The people on the front lines for the long-term, HRC, NGLTF, etc. have paid staff to support them. With very few exeptions, no one who is at the forefront of the movement today was there five years ago, and will not likely be at the forefront in another five years. The burnout rate is terribly high.
You have an incredible talent, so after your downtime, look around some and if you’re not quite ready for another combat tour, think about some other project you’d like to which you can lend those talents. But keep in mind, sometimes you don’t choose a battle, it chooses you.
I have followed your blog for a couple of years but have not commented until now. I have admired your tenacity, your spirit, your courage, and your honesty. When someone works as hard as you have on Amendment One, and come up on the losing side, it’s no surprise that you would be discouraged, tired, and angry even. We are, after all, human, and sometimes things just suck.
But know this Pam: our cause is just and we fight not just for ourselves but for those who come after us. We keep pushing the ball forward for as long as we can. Then others will pick up the ball when we no longer can. While we may suffer some big defeats like the one in North Carolina, many small victories one person, one family, one community at a time, plus the rightness of our cause, will someday turn the tide in our favor. Is it maddeningly slow? Absolutely!
So my advice, if I may offer it, is to set it (the loss) to the side and think about some things that bring you happiness and go do them. For me it’s going to the park and sitting on a swing and imagining that I’m flying while I’m swinging up toward the sky. Listening to the rustling leaves and the wind blowing through my hair makes me happy.
I recently attended an interesting lecture on the subject of xenophobia. Several presenters talked about xenophobia from a broad perspective, all the way from protozoa, through our primitive ancestors, to modern societies. Several observations presented resonated with me. I was struck by the self-perpetuating nature of xenophobia toward LGBT people.
The three primary driving factors of xenophobia are fear, anger, and disgust. I think for LGBT people, the underlying prejudice against us stems mostly from disgust (born of ignorance and a negative reaction to seeing relationships they wouldn’t consider entering) and some fear, but the leaders of the movement against us fabricate lies about us in order to intensify false fear and foster xenophobia in others that might not exist otherwise. These would include painting gay men as pedophiles, claiming same-sex marriages are a threat to “traditional” marriages, and claiming that women are threatened by transwomen in restrooms, etc.
Xenophobia is greatest when one side’s good is seen as being at the expense of the other side’s. Here again, leaders in opposition to us want to claim without any justification that a same-sex marraige down the street will threaten the marriage of a heterosexual couple. Such claims are specifically designe to generate and spread homophobia.
Xenophobia is worse in more diverse societies. More diverse societies are more resistant to sharing resources. This is a surprising observation because it seems counter intitive, but it seems that familiarity breeds contempt. America, being an extremely diverse society, is at greater risk of broad, deep, and organized xenophobia than more homogenious nations. In fact, you could look at it as xenophobia of some kind being an inavoidable consequense of having such a diverse nation, and some group will always be victimized by it.
Bad faith (theology), stupid or crazy are how we perceive people who disagree with us. This is true on both sides. We see those who oppose us this way, and they see us this way as well.
Increasing value of relationship hastens reconciliation after conflict. This is a hopeful observation that should be more exploited. One problem we have with those who oppose us is that they see no value in their relationship with us. They see themselves as losing nothing in suppressing us, while preserving their interests in doing so. This is where we gain from being more out and reaching out from beyond our gayborhoods to play a stronger, more beneficial, and more conspicuous role in the greater society. The more straight society sees and feels value with LGBT people and community, the less they will feel and/or act on xenophobic reactions toward us.
I gave some thought to the invisible in a wheel chair thing that happens a while back. I don’t know about you all, but I recall as a little kid being told it was rude to stare at people who were handicapped in some way. Certainly my kids who don’t seem to find folks in wheel chairs or otherwise visibly handicapped anything other than people, possibly even more fascinating people because of braces, prosthetics, etc. But my way of dealing with a staring kid was to tell them to introduce themselves and ask about whatever. This from knowing so many who were really lonely because of the avoidance a lot of healthy folks practice.
Every differently abled my kids have “stared at” have been thrilled to make friends with my kids, and thrilled to be talked to as a person, not either completely ignored or having a huge part of who they are pointedly ignored. But I think among my age group, a lot of the pretending the disabled are not there comes from being misinformed back as little kids that the [Blind, deaf, crippled, whatever] wanted their disability ignored, that mentioning it or asking questions would “make them uncomfortable”. I know I have to consciously remind myself that someone with a disability would rather talk about it and how it affects them than be treated like a freak. But there is my theory.