Matt Barber of the anti-gay Liberty Counsel is upset.
Apparently a new study has confirmed what many of us knows when it comes to how homophobia hurts gay health:
A conservative attorney disagrees with the findings of “Private Lives 2,” a study of Australian homosexuals that suggests discrimination, not lifestyle, is the reason why homosexuals seek psychological counseling — a conclusion similar to that reached by the American Psychological Association.
The online study was conducted by Malbourne’s La Trobe University with the support of Gay and Lesbian Health Victoria, as well as the Victoria state government and the Australian national depression initiative. But Matt Barber, vice president of Liberty Counsel Action, tells OneNewsNow other research has repeatedly concluded that it is the lifestyle — not discrimination or lack of societal “acceptance” — that results in homosexuals seeking counseling.
He believes groups like the APA have lost credibility over the years by suggesting otherwise.
“The APA has really in large part simply become a political activist organization,” Barber decides. “They are no longer objectively a scientific group that views things through an objective prism; but rather, they are pushing a political, sexual, anarchist agenda.”
He says the APA is helping “to facilitate” those caught up in the lifestyle to continue a destructive, unhealthy, immoral and biologically wrong way of living and thinking. “So for the APA to help them rationalize these behaviors, it’s really irresponsible of the American Psychological Association to do this,” the attorney submits.
That’s the gist of the article. Barber offers no proof of his claims that the APA is a “political organization.” Nor does he offer up any of the “other research” which supposedly concludes that the supposed homosexual lifestyle is the reason for depression in gays.
Basically it comes down to the fact that Barber simply doesn’t like the conclusion of the Australian study and that’s why he is trashing it. Nor does he like the fact that the APA has done research confirming the same conclusions of the Australian study.
You see the Australian study refutes theories put forth by Barber and other religious right phony experts that homosexuality itself is a dangerous “lifestyle.” Usually when folks like Barber push this notion, they cite health statistics, like those from the Centers of Disease Control.
But no legitimate study nor any medical organization has ever said that homosexuality in itself is a “dangerous lifestyle.” They usually cite outside factors, such as homophobia. The following is what the CDC said when it comes to HIV/AIDS amongst gay men:
Stigma and homophobia may have a profound impact on the lives of MSM, especially their mental and sexual health. Internalized homophobia may impact men’s ability to make healthy choices, including decisions around sex and substance use. Stigma and homophobia may limit the willingness of MSM to access HIV prevention and care, isolate them from family and community support, and create cultural barriers that inhibit integration into social networks.
Racism, poverty, and lack of access to health care are barriers to HIV prevention services, particularly for MSM from racial or ethnic minority communities. A recent CDC study found a strong link between socioeconomic status and HIV among MSM: prevalence increased as education and income decreased, and awareness of HIV status was higher among MSM with greater education and income
To put it more succinctly, Matt Barber is typical of the religious right spokespeople. When researchers come out with something they disagree with, they whine about how gays have “infiltrated” or simply cherry-pick the research to push their bogus conclusions about the gay community.
Barber has no expertise in science, research, or health. The reason why he didn’t cite any proof to back up his charges is because he doesn’t have any.
And he knows it.




20 Comments


Matt Barber has no room in his mind for scientifically peer reviewed studies that would hold up in court.
That is why Matt Barber did NOT testify in the Prop 8 trial…
After all, everything Matt Barber knows about gay sex he learned from Peter LaBarbera (though details of the knowledge transfer are guarded secrets).
If appearances count, and I know that is in question, but he looks like one more huge, over-weight, maybe angry or bitter, voice of reason wanta-be. I hope he can find something that he will treasure and enjoy, so he will not need to worry so much about what other people are doing….Whose Liberty is his group looking out for?
“A conservative attorney”?! How is refusing to consider that your actions (discrimination against homosexuals) have consequences (making people feel bad) in any way conservative? Perhaps the adjective Butts was looking for was thoughtless, or maybe sociopathic, both of which describe Barber’s response more accurately?
And conflating homosexuality with an “anarchist agenda”?! That’s quite a control fetish you’ve got there, Barber.
Well, the greater the fear the higher the ideological walls need to be and therefore the less impression the slings and arrows of evidence make.
Great post!
I do believe Barber is projecting. He looks like a bear from the meat market in NYC.
i suspect that when folks like Barber talk about liberty they mean entirely freedom from and not at all freedom to. “I wish to be free from everything I don’t like,” is their understanding of liberty. Out of fear and threat of punishment, they have put the kibosh on their own free thoughts and actions through Control. There is nothing that drives such folks more crazy than seeing others exercise freedom to do as they please. Barber and ilk have let fear and punishment get the best of them, applied rigid controls to assuage that fear, and then seek to do the same to others. And if they don’t similarly control others, how else can they ever be truly safe?
Hey Barber and team, stop being afraid. You’ll be happier–and probably safer. I’m sorry if you didn’t get enough love or confidence-building in your developmental years, but it ain’t too late to try.
Book suggestion o’ the day regarding this post: “Nature’s Rainbow: Diversity, Gender, and Sexuality in Nature and People” by Joan Roughgarden
http://www.amazon.com/Evolutions-Rainbow-Diversity-Gender-Sexuality/dp/0520240731
I disagree, no one gay would sport that haircut.
It’s far simpler to “disagree” than to empathize and fix.
You can generify this headline. It’s easy. Just from now on use:
“Religious Right spokesman says something wrong, obnoxious.”
I also suggest the replacement of “spokesman” with “spokesdick” in the case of these people.
Come on. if that isn’t a rug, Marcus is straight.
The spokesperson, for the Christian Right, appears to have committed the sin of Gluttony.
I wonder when (maybe that should be if) the teachings of Christ will actually penetrate the minds of these people, the parable of “motes and beams” come to mind…
Hmm, maybe the word I’m searching for is Hypocrite.
If there actions are any indication, they abhor the teachings of Christ. On the other hand, they have a fetishistic love for the authority, control and gleeful propensity for punishment of his Daddy.
Er …. umm-mmmm … what would we call Elaine Donnelly or Virginia Foxxnooz or Sally Kern or Michele-one-l Bachmann or Maggie Gallagher or …?
It’s instructive that this piece was published by One News Now, probably because no one else would touch it.
So Barber’s preaching to the choir. And the choir members are all auditioning for Glee.
Let’s also take into account that BamBam’s nothing more than indoctrinated little puppet whose strings are controlled by the Christian Taliban.
Let’s also *never* forget that his little cult is still under legal investigation for assisting Lisa Miller, a wanted felon, escape the United States for Guatemala with a daughter Isabella, whom she abducted because *two* state courts ordered her to release Isabella to the custory of her ex-partner Janet Jenkins!
Surely you don’t expect ethical behavior from those doing God’s Work(TM).
And sin causes leprosy, and miasma causes cholera, and poorly distributed body humours cause schizoprhenia(when it isn’t caused by daemonic possession)
Please!
The last time that religion dictated science we ended up with Galileo before the Inquisition
Barber et all are still using studies by Cameron for their propaganda, usually disguised by quoting secondary sources(citing people who quote cameron but not mentioning Cameron) and Cameron’s figuers and methodology have been thoroughly debunked
“Using Cameron’s figures is like using used toilet paper to touch up your lipstick; it is messy, it stinks and you always regret it”
F C Tronetti