Earlier this month when Minnesota Archbishop John Nienstedt sent out a letter urging every Catholic church in the state to create ad-hoc committees that would work to pass a constitutional amendment against marriage equality, he caused a deserved uproar regarding the idea that a tax-exempt entity would take such an aggressive role in a political issue.
However, there is another issue in this situation which needs more attention:
According to Nienstedt’s letter, the church captains will be organized by the Minnesota Catholic Conference, the public policy arm of the Catholic church, which will in turn report to the Minnesota for Marriage coalition for statewide efforts. Minnesota for Marriage is made up of the Minnesota Family Council, MCC and the National Organization for Marriage.
We all know the exploits of the National Organization for Marriage – how the group moves from state to state scaring up the populace against marriage equality via lies and scare tactics such as claiming that gays are “corrupting” children while fighting state laws demanding that it reveal its donors.
However, let’s focus more on the Minnesota Family Council. People should be reminded that group has a sordid history of homophobia. According to People for the American Way’s Right Wing Watch:
Tom Prichard, the MFC’s president, maintained that LGBT youth commit suicide because they live an “unhealthy lifestyle” and that anti-bullying programs are ways to have children “indoctrinated in homosexuality.” Prichard also criticized Gay Straight Alliances, saying “it’s sad and harmful for kids to celebrate homosexuality when in fact it’s not a healthy lifestyle;” he went on to claim that Matthew Shepard’s murder wasn’t a hate crime and that his “death served an important ideological purpose for homosexual activists.”
Earlier this year, MFC was called out for having materials on its webpage that accused gays of pedophilia, bestiality, and consuming bodily wastes. Prichard later actually defended the inaccurate data. However after much outcry, the materials were removed from the webpage without any comment.
The Minnesota Family Council is scum. It is a group devoted to demonizing and stigmatizing the gay community through junk science and ugly propaganda.
Yet it is the same group that Archbishop Nienstedt seems no problem in teaming up with in order to stop marriage equality in Minnesota.
There is a great deal more at stake than talk of tax-exempt status. The question has to be, is Nienstedt ready to barter the integrity of his Catholic diocese in order to stop marriage equality?
Could it be that Nienstedt is so concerned with the verses of the Bible that supposedly speak against homosexuality that he is abandoning the ones that speak against lying and bearing false witness?




18 Comments


People like him pick and choose which parts of the Bible are correct, based on God’s personal messages to him and his own personal prejudices.
Boxturtle (They do the same thing with Campaign finance laws)
The catholic church IS the devil.
My sex life , What’s it to you ?
Like that English cleric reminded us the money and greed are a top billing in the Bible the obsession with sex not so much.
I’m a non-practicing Catholic and live just a few miles south of Minnesota.
Has there been much of a response from the catholic rank and file? I’d be interested in what sort of reaction or feedback the hierarchy has gotten. Are there any sorts of active grassroots groups among catholics opposed to the church’s stand making any public statements?
It’s astounding how such a poorly-written collection of claptrap as the bible has persisted for centuries as a means of behavior control of the masses by the elite.
Why can’t we have their tax exempt status revoked? I am continually amazed at how these institutions can operate in direct contravention of the Tax Code. Not only can they violate the spirit, but indeed, the letter of the law with complete impunity. Obviously there are some religions which enjoy immunity from the law. It must stop!
I’m extremely concerned about how often I must type certain words. “Immunity from the law”, “Illegal”, “unfair”, “Unconstitutional”, “Fascist”, “Oligarch”, etc. That is why I am “Nonplussed”, for I have been thoroughly disabused of notions which I had held gospel for so much of my life. It takes time to become deprogrammed from a lifetime of DoD indoctrination-both as a dependent and a service member. I believed the USA was something it wasn’t, and arguably never was.
I have no problem with churches’ being involved in political action – as long as they’re willing to give up their tax exemption. I don’t agree with 90% of what churches today are advocating outside their church doors; they certainly enjoy the right to petition their government for a redress of their grievances. But there is no good reason why they should not be paying taxes – there never has been.
Are you serious? The Catholic
sheepfaithful have not stood up to their leaders in any meaningful way since the Reformation.Pretty much the only rank and file left are the ones who share their clergy’s bigotry. The rest of us packed up and left a long time ago.
What happened to that church/state separation thing?
The Catholic church has integrity?
This is understandable….right?
Take no action against priests who molest children..except to move them to another parish but violate the separation of church and state and my belief that all are equal under the law….
AMEN….brother
Nonplussed, SueDe, Marblex, and everyone,
According to the IRS code, churches (and all 501(c)3 orgs) may be engaged in issue politics; the only prohibition is that they may not support specific candidates.
So to everyone who is outraged that churches get involved in these anti-equality ballot initiatives: Sorry! It’s perfectly legal.
Catholics and journalists need to ask just one question to end all this foolishness:
How much church money is spent on ending starvation, illness, illiteracy, and environmental damage, vs. how much church money is wasted denying equal civil rights for America’s 31 million LGBT citizens?
Once churchgoers see those figures, they’ll put a stop to the bigotry overnight.
Yeah, sure, just like they’ve put a stop to child-rape by priests, for which Holy Mother Church has paid out more than a billion dollars in settlements and hush money worldwide. Dream on.
You might be interested in checking out Catholics for Equality.
What’s this world coming to? If ya wuz to go ’round telling little sissies “no, offing yerself wouldn’t leave behind a cleaner world for all us non-unnatural-type folks,” why they might start getting ideas. Like they deserve to live or sumthin.