Hey, I hope we don’t see HRC making any bold statements about ENDA until they speak to California U.S. Rep. Jackie Speier. She believes that employment discrimination protection is “realistically” not in the cards for five years.
Addressing the crowd of gay and straight political and community leaders at Sunday’s Alice B. Toklas LGBT Democratic Club Pride breakfast, Speier said, “Speaker [Nancy] Pelosi is doing all she can to ensure a majority for next year so we can pass ENDA.”Asked later in a brief interview if that meant the House would not vote on ENDA this year, Speier told the B.A.R. , “The rest of the year is in question.”
“There’s no question ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’ will be history this year,” she said. “ENDA, we will have that law for sure within the next five years.”
Speier, a Democrat whose district includes parts of San Mateo and San Francisco counties, said she was acknowledging reality.
“I’m being realistic,” she said.
The folks in the room weren’t happy (as you would be seething if you were there). Masen Davis, executive director of the Transgender Law Center and Equality California Executive Director Geoff:
“That means we’ll have five years of people being fired,” he said. “Putting a five-year time limit on the bill feels out of touch.”…”In a difficult economic climate, it is abhorrent not to pass protections for some of the most vulnerable members of our community, especially when public support for ENDA is higher than for other priorities Congress has pushed through,” Kors said.
I would think that “fierce advocacy” and bully pulpit elbow-twisting to move ENDA might reduce that timeline, don’t you? Out of the major legislation that were on our priority list – DADT, ENDA, DOMA, we’re still limping along after two years with only a hate crimes law (that would have passed anyway) and a crippled DADT repeal that we still don’t even know will pass.
The level of mixed messaging out there regarding legislative process should disturb everyone.



6 Comments



realistically…we’re waiting for a bunch of people to die and a lot of the younger folks to come of age.
Is anything she said sane?“”There’s no question ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’ will be history this year,”
What legislation is she reading? Is there a secret deal we don’t know about that will end DADT by Dec 31?
DADT will be in place into 2011.
And the gall to tell your base that ENDA isn’t coming for five years… Way to fire up the troops.
Congresswoman, to speak in a language you understand:
You won’t be getting my direct or indirect support (in the form of votes, money and time) for your hapless federal Democratic party for five years.
I’m just being realistic.
Five Years Might Be Too OptimisticDon’t forget, folks, in five years there might be another GOPer in the White House, which means someone who would likely veto that future ENDA.
And if a GOPer is elected in 2012, that means we could not have another Democrat (a true “fierce” advocate, maybe?) until January 2017. But if a GOPer gets elected in 2012, and if [s]he gets reelected in 2016, that means there’s not a chance for another Democratic president until January 2021.
And all of this assumes, of course, that Democrats run Congress all that time, or that GOPers give up gay-bashing as a GOTV technique, or both.
Hell, sometimes it seems more realistic to believe in the Easter Bunny. At least, he comes every year.
I say againDemocrats have no balls and are unwilling to stand up for our rights as equal citizens. Vote with a lawsuit.
I have mixed feelings on this In truth, it’s it better for them to keep promising ENDA is this year, next year, two weeks… As they’ve been doing for so long? The mixed messaging certainly does indicate the Democratic Caucus is not all on the same page on when, or if, it will ever become a priority.
So I encourage them to speak to us like grown ups, and recognize realities. Of course, that would include identifying the actual hurdles it has to jump. And that causes a problem for the Democratic Caucus. Are they going to call out the Democrats in their own party like, Sen Blanche Lincoln that won’t help it get through the Senate? Doubt it.
The alternative to frank talk that “it’s five years away” is the debacle of President Barack Obama’s messaging. Recall he promised us the moon and the stars in the campaign.
And ten minutes after getting inaugurated he went silent and our community was barraged by his supporters that “There are political realities! He doesn’t have a magic wand! Be quiet and be patient!”
So, I don’t know that I’m enraged being told it’s five years off. But I do wish the frank talk would include very specific talk of what exactly–and who–is in the way today.
Fear! Fear!Remember, we have to keep voting for the minimalist incrementalist Democrats because otherwise a Republican will come in and there will be no progress!
“What’s the Matter with Kansas”, Democrat-style.