With news breaking of Kip Williams of GetEQUAL mounting yet another civilly disobedient action to keep pressure on the issue of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” repeal, I thought it’d be a good time to share this.
I had an occasion to mention an action from the 1980s, by the AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power (ACT UP) and was rather surprised to find out how many young people do not know of their actions.
I lived through the time, and though their stakes were life and death, like GetEQUAL, they suffered from much of the same criticism, that they were too extreme, that they were uncivilized, they were an embarrassment and turning off allies.
I believe thousands of people are alive today, because ACT UP acted, when others waited.
After the jump, a look at our community’s history with civil disobedience, in case they skipped that in history class, for some of you kids.
In the beginning, there was Stonewall. And it was a riot.
Everything old is new again. The modern gay rights movement is popularly believed to have been born on June 27, 1969, at an event known as the Stonewall riots. The anniversary of Stonewall is celebrated on the last Sunday in June each year with Pride marches in New York, San Francisco and across the nation and globe.
But the amidst the misty nostalgia and grateful recognition of how far the LGBT community has come, many forget, not only that was it violent riot, it was a spontaneous act of civil disobedience.
Rather than submit to the usual and unremarkable arrests and shakedowns of the New York City police that were commonplace at gay establishments at the time, the patrons of the Stonewall Inn said together: “Enough!” And they resisted arrest. And they rose up and assaulted cops, with cans, bottles, rocks and their fists. And it lasted for days.
History vindicated these accidental activists’ assault on the New York City’s law men. In 2004 original veterans, both rioters and police reunited, marching together in the New York City Gay Pride parade to mark the 35th anniversary of the riot. The site was designated by the Federal Government as a national historic landmark in 1999. [More on Stonewall here.]
Another thing often overlooked is, in the process of this civil disobedience, the gay community obtained a Civil Right previously denied them: the right to free association. Prior to the Stonewall incident, in most places gay bars or gathering establishments were considered illegal and open targets for raids and police harassment. It was presumed it was within the government’s appropriate jurisdiction to dictate to LGBT Americans who they may or may not fraternize with. Though raids unfortunately continue to this day, it is now properly accepted that the LGBT citizens are permitted the right of free association like any other American.
As the radical political tactics of the 60s and 70s fell from fashion in the 80s, the LGBT community, too, transitioned into more docile and mainstream tactics of lobbying for legal equality. There was a the rise of traditional lobbying groups, like Human Campaign Rights. Radicalism gave way to K-Street offices and cocktail parties.
The Rise of ACT UP
Then the AIDS crisis hit. Though earliest cases were identified in 1981, by the late 80s, the government response-from the Center for Disease Control, the National Institute of Health and the Federal Drug Administration-was still lackadaisical, impotent and wholly insufficient to address the tens of thousands of annual deaths that were ravaging the gay community.
By 1987, recognizing neither our elected leaders, nor our K-Street lobbying groups were getting the job done, a group of activists, sprang to action. Calling themselves the AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power (ACT UP) they mounted a long series of spectacularly headline-grabbing civil disobedient actions. These included:
• On March 24, 1987, ACT UP NY shut down the New York Stock Exchange, resulting in 73 arrests.
• On April 15, 1987 they disrupted taxpayers filing last-minute tax returns at NYC’s General Post Office.
• On January 31, 1988, ACT UP shut down the Golden Gate Bridge during rush-hour ruining many Bay Area resident’s daily commute.
The idea: to make it no longer so convenient for America to continue to ignore the AIDS crisis. And, in the end, an apathetic Federal Government was prodded into using their resources at the FDA, NIH and CDC to address the crisis that had swept the LGBT community unnoticed for years. [More on ACT UP here and here.]
In March 2007, as the Employment Non-Discrimination Act languished for its 34th year in the United States Congress, a founding member of ACT UP, Larry Kramer made the call to a new generation to also act up:
Kramer said that today’s judges who rule against same-sex marriage and politicians who vote against laws to expand rights for lesbian and gay people are “equally threatening as AIDS” used to be.
“I think the courts that continue to deny us our rights are evil,” Kramer said. “We are not equal, and I’m sick of it, and every gay person should be sick of it and every gay person should be ashamed if they’re ‘passing.’”
Matt Foreman of the National Gay & Lesbian Task Force agrees. Days later, immediately after his own arrest protesting “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” at a Army recruitment Center in NYC, he said:
“I do feel that the time for direct action is back,” said Foreman, who was last arrested at a protest in 1991. “One thing the movement has lacked for many years is a left flank. We got where we did with AIDS because we had ACT UP on one hand and the professionals in suits on the other.”

One of the people responding to the call for direct action is Robin McGehee. Appropriately, her organization has taken its name from the simplicity of its goal: to GetEQUAL. GetEqual has taken the lead in organizing acts of civil disobedience and engaging in other newsworthy protests. You may remember when, recently, the President’s speech was interrupted during a fundraiser for Senator Barbara Boxer. That was GetEqual. And they were the instigators when on April 20th:
![]()
Six people in military uniforms*, including Lt. Dan Choi, handcuffed themselves to the North Lawn fence of the White House today to protest the fact that the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy has not been repealed.
[*Note: these were actual servicemembers and veterans, not costumed protestors as CBS and other media outlets implied. The information to verify that was made readily available.]
Just days ago, GetEqual members held protests demanding passage of ENDA in Washington DC and Chicago, with some arrests.

GetEqual’s tactics seem to have also spurred on copy-cat work from other LGBT grassroots activists. In recent months groups not affiliated with GetEqual, have mounted civilly disobedient actions at the New York City Marriage Bureau, a sit-in at Senator John McCain’s office and Senator Dick Durbin’s office, and HIV activists used a Presidential visit in New York to stage a protest of HIV funding cuts. Eight activists were arrested that day.
I say good for them. Let’s make it inconvenient for them to keep ignoring us.
———————————————————-
This diary served as an introduction to a liveblog hosting of GetEQUAL founder Robin McGehee that was first posted at The Daily Kos. A Q&A session can be found there, as well as the thread of her chat.
Daily Kos hosts a regular series GLBT and Friends at Daily Kos that posts every Friday at 11:30 am EST. New users are welcome to join us to discuss issues concerning LGBT politics and culture.



19 Comments





Wonderful summary. Thanks.I’ve posted before about how ACT UP was instrumental in getting Pittsburgh’s gay rights law passed. In brief, their actions made the “city fathers” (including Mayor Sophie Masloff) desperate to deal with the Pittsburgh Fairness Campaign, the “moderate” group in town. What they never realized was that the membership of the two groups was largely identical. ”Radical,” confrontational actions are to key to moving politicians forward who would never budge an inch without them.
(As an aside, my own proudest moment of civil disobedience came during the 1968 campaign, when I hit George Wallace with a pie. I still feel all warm and fuzzy when I think about it.)
Thanks clarknt. I posted under a GETEQUAL notice on my fb today, a reminder……About how we in the medical community were so despairng we would ever be able to help the thousands dying of AIDS… It was ACTUP and their very brave actions that saved literally thousands and thousands of lives by forcing BIG PHARMA to find medicines we might still not have today. These antivirals were also useful immediately in other viral illnesses too, not just HIV.I had heard how ACT=UP was careful to design each action to be most effective for the a specific area of the recalcitrant reasearch and development side of HHS and BIG PHARMA.So far, I think GET EQUAL and SLDN have been doing admirably… After all, what has waiting 'for the time to be ripe' at HRC get us. 17 years of DADT, DOMA, no ENDA and no UAFA… NOTHING…They did not get us the MATTHEW SHEPARD Act… Judy Shepard did, no matter what they want to claim.That's right, I am sorry the produced a list of companies that claim to support LGBT rights, but don't in many cases. TA DA!…oh, and lots and lots of donations from those who cannot bear the thought of coming out of the closet of GAY, INC. Remember as DOROTHY said.
Though a condensed versionthis should be a must read for all LGBT youth.
There is much more to be told in the long version, such as the history of the Mattachine society, groundbreakers in the photography field such as Bob Mizer of AMG, and many others.
There is history and we need to pass it on.
Great Post!My political memory begins in the 90′s so it’s always good to read LGBT history.
It should be noted, there were several civil disobedience arrests this past week concerning immigration. I’m proud to say that members of Out4Immigration were there fighting for the UAFA. I hope the LGBT community does not forget them and includes them in the history of the LGBT civil rights struggle.
Other milestones…
A similar to Stonewall “spontaneous” rebellion involved largely transgender people in San Francisco three years before.
In 1987, most of the best known gay leaders in the country were arrested in front of the White House protesting Reagan’s passive genocide by AIDS. They included Rev. Troy Perry, Steve Endean, Jean O’Leary, Dan Bradley, David Mixner, Jim Foster, Phil Pannell, Sean Strub, Ginny Apuzzo, and
And in 1993, David Mixner was one of those arrested again in front of the White House protesting the announcement of DADT.
If our worst fears about this “compromise” prove true, I expect and hope for a great deal of civil disobedience in our future. I spoke to Dan Choi today and he’s NOT going away!
Seems to be some problems with pic of David. Let’s try again.
Yeah, it’s very woefully incompleteAnd yeah, I am aware of the Mattachine Society, One magazine, and other efforts that predated Stonewall. But, honestly, I was just shocked to find young (20-something) LGBT posters on Kos that didn’t even know about Act Up. How quickly we forget. And we mustn’t. We really need to address the issue of educating our youth. Because, unless they take a Queer Studies course at a liberal college, no one will. We’re wiped from the history books.
I’d be curious to see how many High School text books leave out our history in WWII’s holocaust. I wouldn’t be surprised if it was 50%.
We oldsters have done a poor job of teaching our historyThank you for the reminder as to why it is vitally important that we do.
Which is why we need to push our own history booksThey do exist. In my own library:
Making Gay History: The Half Century Fight for Lesbian and Gay Equal Rights, Eric Marcus, 2002
Gay Seattle: Stories of Exile and Belonging, Gary Atkins, 2003
Christianity, Social Tolerance, and Homosexuality: Gay People in Western Europe from the Beginning of the Christian Era to the Fourteenth Century, John Boswell, 1985
Gay American History: Lesbians and Gay Men in the U.S.A., Jonathan Ned Katz, 1992
Another Mother Tongue, Judy Grahn, 1990
There are lots more, not even counting the many local GLBT history projects.
thanksso many forget about Compton’s and that it predated stonewall. and that the T were the first to start in both.
Some more histeryI have been looking around the web for GLBT histery, and came up with the Outweek Internet Archive that ran from 1989 to 1991 with 105 issuse’s.
Download the PDF copys and see the histery.
http://www.outweek.net/archive…
The lessons of history need continual revisiting — Why We Can’t WaitI’m active in a civil-disobedience movement to desegregate mosques for women, and the moderates are always scolding us radicals that we’re ruining all the careful, cautious, timid, glacially slow progress they’ve been making all these years. All of the lame arguments that were used against the Civil Rights movement are being thrown at us now– even though our critics know nothing of the history of such movements, which are now enshrined in a vague, hazy glow on Dr. King’s birthday, with all the rough edges of the truth smoothed over.
The moderates, i.e. those helping to perpetuate the unjust status quo, either don’t know the history of civil disobedience movements, or deny that such lessons of history apply to any such movement that’s actually in their face in the present.
Precisely. Dr. Martin Luther King’s Why We Can’t Wait should be required reading for any movement for equal rights. Dr. King addressed such stick-in-the-mud criticism with eloquent, reasoned arguments for pushing harder to overcome inertia. This inertia will never be overcome unless we push hard.
Sorry, but…
The only thing I can recommend this book be used for is as an example of trans-erasure.
For actual history, I recommend:
Transgender History, Susan Stryker, 2008
How Sex Changed, Joanne Meyerowitz, 2002
This tendency is so frustrating
and yes, those who scold Kip Williams would likely have had equally terse words for King had they been around.
I can’t imagine what they would have to say about those gays that assaulted policemen at Stonewall.
CIVIL disobedienceLet me say for now I think we should be clear as to what civil disobedience means, as there are various conceptions ‘out there,’ some of them quite disparate in formulation and effect. I’m not at all convinced that the actions (as described in the link) of the animal liberations activists would properly qualify as CIVIL disobedience according to most conceptions, some of which, for instance ‘the Gandhian,’ are quite demanding as regards the behavior of the individual or group engaged in the selected nonviolent violation of a law or laws. I recall a compilation by Hugo Adam Bedau (several decades ago) that helped illustrate the various moral and political reasons that might be used to justify civil disobedience in a would-be democratic polity, and I’m trying to track down a publication on this topic by the Center for the Study of Democratic Institutions (founded by Robert Maynard Hutchins), which was based in Santa Barbara, California from 1958-1987. I know there are some recent publications on this subject but I’ve yet to read them.
This is from 1995 WQED’s “The Question of Equality.”…
I certainly grant I’ve used a very liberaldefinition of Civil Disobedience in this context.
I’m curious what you mean by “animal liberations activists.”
By what sense of definition of “animals” are you using. And which activists? All o them I’m referencing? Or would you please be more specific who is an “animal” and why?
Thank you for the recommendations n/t
Thank youThat book was infuriating. That pompous author was basically saying “You people don’t exist, and even if you do exist, you don’t count for anything, so get lost.”