Well, it’s good to see this long-time frustration with being an ATM getting traction. In the February Advocate, activists and bloggers who have been leading the charge to hold the Democrats responsible for their lame, limited, spineless “support” of LGBT rights, are simply tired of the party’s hand always out looking for your cash assuming you’re too dumb to see that you’re really being pickpocketed.
In the wake of the Maine defeat, a coterie of liberal bloggers and activists called for a temporary moratorium on DNC donations. The fledgling movement, which has adopted the motto “Don’t Ask, Don’t Give” and has attracted the likes of legendary gay rights activist David Mixner, hopes to discourage donations to the party until the passage of the Employment Non-Discrimination Act and the repeal of both “don’t ask, don’t tell” and the Defense of Marriage Act. In so doing, these activists are hoping to reshape-if not completely upset-the relationship between gays and the Democratic Party.
…With the 2010 midterm congressional election looking increasingly perilous for progressives, thus making the imperative to pass pro-gay legislation before then all the more urgent, a picture is beginning to emerge of a Democratic president and political party that are, as [Andy] Szekeres describes them, happy to take money and votes from gay people but less inclined to spend political capital on their behalf. So far, the only piece of significant gay rights legislation to pass Congress and receive the president’s signature is the expansion of the hate-crimes act, which was ultimately appended to a defense spending bill. Hearings on ENDA and the repeal of DADT have been delayed, and the prospects for getting DOMA off the books are dimming. Perhaps candidate Obama made too many promises; even some of his strongest supporters acknowledge that his early guarantees for change may be coming back to haunt him. “I wish he had said he was a ‘firm and steady ally’ rather than a ‘fierce advocate,’ ” says one prominent gay Democrat.
Losses on the state level have only darkened impressions of the DNC in the eyes of some gay activists. In addition to the revocation of equal marriage rights in Maine, the New York state senate rejected a marriage equality bill in December, with eight Democrats joining all of the chamber’s Republicans. At press time it appears marriage in New Jersey, which once looked like a surefire bet, may not make it through the legislature. “Many of us in the progressive movement just want to throw up,” Steven Goldstein of Garden State Equality told Newark’s Star-Ledger. “Democrats put out one hand to ask for money, and with the other they stab you in the back.“
Oh my god, you have to click over to see the photo they used of Andy Tobias. A little free-form commentary? LOLOLOL.
How about these sample quotes of this “holy war” featured in the article:
“The goal is freedom. And we have to go get it. They’re not going to give it to us. In stead of pumping money into the Democratic Party right now, we should be pumping money into our struggle for civil rights. Lobbying Washington. Challenging state ballot initiatives. Engaging in civil disobedience…. There’s no one right way.”
- Activist and blogger David Mixner“We’re just saying we’re going to take you [the Democratic Party] down with us. We’re going to blow this up and it’s going to hurt you too.”
– AmericaBlog editor John Aravosis“The administration is going to continue to make steady progress on our issues whether we help strengthen its hand or not. But the stronger it is, the faster that progress will come.”
– Democratic National Committee treasurer Andrew Tobias
I want to note that the matter of the gAyTM is more symbolism that anything else, since the DNC and DNCC rely on big-time politicos who bundle donations; small dollar donors, as you have seen don’t carry much weight with these folks.
The most effective statement average people can convey is to use those mailed fundraising appeals as opportunities to convey your sentiments, and when the phone rings asking for money, that you politely tell the person on the other end why your dollars will go to candidates you support, not party infrastructure that doesn’t work for you. Obviously, if you have the ear of big dollar donors to influence that’s always a plus, but the movement to symbolically show dissatisfaction with the status quo isn’t unsophisticated or irrelevant.



In the wake of the Maine defeat, a coterie of liberal bloggers and activists called for a temporary moratorium on DNC donations. The fledgling movement, which has adopted the motto “Don’t Ask, Don’t Give” and has attracted the likes of legendary gay rights activist David Mixner, hopes to discourage donations to the party until the passage of the Employment Non-Discrimination Act and the repeal of both “don’t ask, don’t tell” and the Defense of Marriage Act. In so doing, these activists are hoping to reshape-if not completely upset-the relationship between gays and the Democratic Party.
34 Comments



Won’t vote for Obama again.If Obama runs unopposed for the Democratic candidate, then I’ll be voting Republican. With all due respect, if neither side is going to do shit for equality, I might as well vote for a candidate that actually does something. Pretty words are all well and good, but that and a quarter still won’t buy you a cup of coffee.
OopsShould have said “I might as well vote for a candidate actually does something in other areas” – otherwise it makes no sense, LOL.
Nothing NewWe “little people” in the GLBT community have been saying this for a long time – these people aren’t geniuses for simply repeating what we’ve been saying all along.
PSCan’t wait for Joe Solmonese to throw a hissy.
AgreedAfter our defeat in my homestate (NJ) last week where 9 Democrats voted against marriage equality (or didn’t vote at all), I’m done with the Democrats. I’ll vote for a third party with no chance over Obama and the NJ Dems.
I am very glad this idea is gaining tractionIf we want change, we will have to do it ourselves.
questionshall I remain registered as a Dem. and vote other parties.
or should I register as an IND. or Green or other?
what would make the most impact?
I’m not voting republicanNot in a million years. I despise the Republican Party.
I may just not vote as neither side seems to be worth supporting.
However…IF Obama gets DADT repealed and ENDA passed than I will revisit this issue. I can say that.
Agreed
remain a dem…and when they call for money, give them an earful!
Depends upon state and party rulesgoverning primary voting.
For instance, in CA “undeclared” registered voters aka what people mistakenly refer to as “independent” can vote on the Democratic Party primary ticket but not the Republican Party ticket. Check local regulations before making your decision.
I’m registered Dem and vote the Democratic primary, but only vote for pro-equality candidates ie. not Obama.
i love the picturei pretty much feel that the political system is broken. not only has obama not provided the change he let us think we were getting, but the other new democrats are starting to sound like all the rest. the democrats and republicans don’t believe in health care for all americans so i’m not looking for my rights anytime soon. no one is getting my money. i think this country is ‘over’, the system is too corrupt to fix. when my parents are gone, and they’re late eighties, i’m thinking it is time to see how other countries ‘feel’ to live in. as an atheist, a gay person, a person that isn’t interested in money and things, perhaps another country is more welcoming. democrats think we have no choice, that they are the only option. wrong. some will vote republican, at least they are predictable in what they promise. some will vote for new democrats and take out incumbents. many won’t vote at all. i need to live in a place that won’t let me die homeless on the street. i am veteran that cannot get mental health care from the va. my crazy isn’t service connected so how far back on the list do you think i am? if i make too much money i won’t have my va care as i have to requalify every year to make sure i’m still poor. other countries may have their negatives but perhaps they are more tolerable negatives…especially after the religious people take over. i’m having a bitter day, sorry.
Never been a Dem, registered or otherwise but…I vote Dem more often than not…
Still, we need to support the Green Party and to get people in office at the local levels. If we can’t threaten the Dems electorally at all levels (local, state, federal) then this means nothing. But this is an important step.
I AM VOTING FOR HARVEY MILKas a Write-In candidate. We need to show how many of us there are and how displeased we are with the Democrats. VOTE FOR HARVEY and show your state how many of us are out in the LGBTI community that are sick and tired of being taken for granted by the Democratic Party.
For me, that includes telling the Joe Solmonese’s of the DCestablishment to kiss my hairy gay ass.
Apparently you’re a single issue voter?Voting for a republican who “actually does something”? What, like start a new war? Is it Reagan or Bush who is your model?
That’s completely idiotic. This hyperbole helps absolutely nobody but the teabaggers.
I haven’t been registered Democratic since the mid-90sand I still get fundraising calls from them. It’s easier to get rid of cockroaches.
Yeah, because Obama’s been so good for peace.
Eventually those local votes for REAL progressiveswill percolate upward. It will take a long time, but there’s no hope otherwise.
As I said at the other placeI am so friggin jealous of you…
permanent interests, not permanent friendsI can’t remember who said that, but it was the first thing to come to mind reading this post.
Democrats generally are better in terms of treating LGBTs like human beings compared to Republicans, but it has become a situation where they take gays for granted. That is the only way I can explain the NY vote on marriage equality.
On the other hand, GOProud and Log Cabin have had zero impact on changing the Republican platform.
I believe in keeping pressure on whoever is in office, but my own interests have gone towards supporting third parties. I have voted for them the last 3 presidential elections (mainly because of the electoral college, which means TN is going to a Republican anyway) but will start voting for them in local elections.
Obama and peaceDid you vote for him?
He’s done exactly what he said he would; gradual withdrawal in Iraq and escalation in Afghanistan. I strongly disagree with him on both but he was still the right choice.
Yeah, that’s why I have voted 3rd parties toochiefly in 2000 with Nader and I didn’t feel bad about sitting out ’96, here in Illinois you can kinda do that. I did vote for Kerry (I held my nose from the stench)…I did vote for Obama (the home field adv. which both he and Hillary would have had)…
Also, I’ve never registered for a party and don’t plan on it anytime soon.
yes!Your right! Everyone must know it.
I agree the DNC is full of snakes, but…some state-level Democratic organizations have a good record for aggressively supporting equality. Washington is one example where much progress was made in just the past four years: comprehensive and inclusive anti-discrimination laws (employment, housing, public accomodations, commercial transactions, etc), expanded hate-crimes laws, and “everything-but-marriage” domestic partnership laws. None of this existed in 2005. Significant progress was also made in Oregon, Colorado and Iowa.
Legislative assemblies in other states passed marriage equality laws (Maine, New Hampshire, California) though sometimes they were thwarted by a people’s referendum (Maine) or governor’s veto (California). I agree that the DNC is full of snakes, but some state level party organizations deserve support.
It ends with Civil DisobedienceBut not everyone wants to put their life in chaos. Civil Disobedience can disturb your American dream but it can also enhance it. One gains freedom and self esteem by fighting for justice in a democratic society. I have protested DOMA since 2004 by not paying Federal and State Income tax but I can’t give advice to others because we are all different..
How is this logical?As i recall, all but one of the votes in favor of SSM in NJ were from Democrats. The Republicans were virtually unanimous in their opposition.
How does that reflect badly on the Democrats?
This is the same logic used by the LCRs. The Democrats have to muster unanimous support in order to avoid blame, while the Republicans can be 100% in opposition and no one cares.
While democrats are more likely to support LGBT initiatives, it is not a REQUIREMENT of membership.
There are ALOTof single issue voters. I find it odd myself. But then again, I value a wide array of issues.
To those single issue voters, I hope that they enjoy bowing down before their Republican overlords.
Sane people know that these things take time.
Does not work that way…In a first past the post, sinner take all environment, third parties don’t win, they simply help one of the opposing parties and distorts the political outcome.
Its sort of like the ratings for Fox News. By themselves they look successful because they are the single conservative outlet for news on TV. Other channels look less successful because they spread their viewership across multiple channels. The result is that Fox looks more important than it really is and always wins the ratings wars.
Fragmenting liberal votes between Democrats and Greens only helps Republicans in the end (which is why the GOP has been known to help fund Green Party candidates).
Actually, I am a two issue voter: basic civil rights and fundamental human dignity.I just cannot understand why you or anyone else would dismiss these issues so easily.
Missing page???Somebody must have told Advocate to toe the party line. The story link on their website gives a message about story not found on the server. Has the HRC struck again or was Uncle Barney unhappy?
Too bad for the Dems thenGuess they shouldn’t be lying scumbags, then. I’m Green, all the way, the Democrats can kiss my ass. The Democrats need to be reminded that they need to keep their promises.
Depends on what and where you do it…A Republican will not win in certain places…
I’m sorry, I, too, value a wide range of issues and I am very disaffected with the Dems now. And have been for awhile
The Dems need to win my vote, my vote does not belong to them just because they sweet talk better than the other guy…