Update: Added Further reading and Related reference links, as well as a reference Further listening audio file.
~~Autumn~~
From Church Report:
Lisa Miller, who was ordered by a court in Vermont to turn over her child to her former partner, has missed the 1pm EST deadline. A Vermont judge had ordered Lisa Miller to turn over daughter Isabella to Janet Jenkins at 1 p.m. Friday at the Falls Church, Va., home of Jenkins’ parents.This case has drawn worldwide attention as Miller and Janet Jenkins were lesbian partners. After a civil union ceremony in 2000, Miller was artificially inseminated and gave birth to a daughter. In 2003, the couple separated and Miller (the birth mother) renounced her homosexuality and became an evangelical Christian…
The Washington Post added the following in their article Va. woman fails to give up child to ex-partner:
…Miller did not show up with the girl, said Sarah Star, Jenkins’ Vermont-based attorney. Jenkins has notified Fairfax County, Va., police that Isabella is missing, Star said.“She’s very disappointed, obviously,” Star said. “She’s very concerned about Isabella and asks that if anybody sees Isabella, that they please contact the authorities.” …
…[Vermont Family Court Judge William]Cohen awarded custody to Jenkins on Nov. 20 after finding Miller in contempt of court for denying Jenkins access to the girl. The judge said the only way to ensure equal access to the child was to switch custody.
But Cohen also noted that it appeared Miller had stopped speaking to her attorneys and “disappeared” with the child…
So, it was suspected earlier this week that Lisa Miller, who in the last month “disappeared” and stopped talking to her lawyers, was not going turn over custody of the former couple’s child in accordance with a court order. Today is the day the custody hand-over was supposed to formally occur. Lisa Miller, the ex-lesbian partner in the dissolved civil union, is now a potential felon because she’s now interfering with the legal custody of a child. From CBS News yesterday:
If Miller does not turn over Isabella, the most likely scenario is that she would be held in contempt of court and a warrant would be issued for her arrest, said Cheryl Hanna, a professor of constitutional law at Vermont Law School.
~~~~~
Further Listening:
* From Concerned Women For America‘s U.S. Supreme Court Refuses to Hear Lisa Miller Case (October 6, 2008 – call this “opposition listening”):
~~~~~
Further Reading:
* Washington Post: About Isabella (February 4, 2007)
* Newsweek: Mrs. Kramer Vs. Mrs. Kramer; It’s an old story-parents split and fight for custody. But when both are women, and one says she is no longer gay, it gets complicated.
* Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders (GLAD): Miller-Jenkins v. Miller-Jenkins (“Since 2004, GLAD has been representing Vermont resident Janet Jenkins for all appellate matters in an ongoing dispute with her former civil union spouse, Lisa Miller, over the shared parenting of their daughter, Isabella.”)
* Lifesite: Exclusive Interview with Lisa Miller, Ex-Lesbian Fighting for Custody of Own Child against “Civil Union” Partner (Opposition reading)
* Facebook: Only One Mommy: The Story of Lisa and Isabella Miller (Opposition Facebook group — jointly run in the past by the Liberty Counsel and Lisa Miller)
~~~~~
Related:
* Janet Jenkins/Lisa Miller custody case still not resolved despite judge’s orders
* Isabella Miller-Jenkins, Christian Nationalism, And The Presidential Election




35 Comments


Really,, is anyone surprised?The religious right would rather break the law than acknowledge us as human beings. And they do this while wrapping themselves in the American flag. Lisa Miller has been thoroughly brainwashed.
It won’t surprise me one bit when we discover that members of the Thomas Road Baptist “Chruch” are found to have been harboring her or to have otherwise aided and abetted this criminal kidnapping.
I hope it works out for Janet and little IsabellaCertainly my prayers are with all involved, specifically little Isabella an Janet Jenkins.
I also think it’s important for this situation to be defined the right way. Jenkins is also Isabella’s parent but I have read several headlines that make it seem that Miller is being “forced” to hand over her daughter to a “stranger.”
That is so inaccurate. And I hope there is more clarification of the situation.
What are the facts in this case?I’d love to ‘do battle’ with some of the Reich supporters in the comments section of other blogs/articles on this topic. I just need THE facts to refute the myths that have sprung up. The big one is that Janet Jenkins, the nonbiological parent, ignored her daughter for five years before suddenly demanding custody. The spreaders of this misinformation then go on to say that the 5-year lapse followed by sudden demands for custody is in support for the (wait for it…) “Homosexual Agenda!!!” (da-da-da-dum!)
To refute this, I need to know what actually happened. I need URLs to articles that support the fact-based narrative.
The longer the reich gets to bay their lies and misinformation, the harder it is to clean up the mess.
Sorry about the typos…I’m breaking in a new keyboard that’s very different from the one I used for about 12 years.
Since 2004 at leastGLAD has been representing Jenkins since 2004. Read up on it here.
Also, try the newsweek articleThe Newsweek article is also good. It’s where I got a lot of my information - http://www.newsweek.com/id/172…
Pointing out the obviousThe right has a habit of ignoring facts in favor of their preconceived ideas.
Just saying…
Not surprised…harboring fugitives is a proud tradition among right wing southern Christianists – see Eric Rudolph.
Ignoring or Covering Up?Just saying…
The sad thing is…that undoubtedly Miller and her enablers have so poisoned Isabella’s mind against Jenkins that it will be difficult of not impossible for Jenkins to have any sort of relationship with Isabella.
The longer Miller is allowed to keep Isabella, the more solidified that poison will have become.
I added a link and……and an audio link about the case — both from October 2008.
The two adds give the Christian Nationalist/Conservative “Christian” perspective on the story from October of last year.
From the Pam’s House Blend diary entitled Isabella Miller-Jenkins, Christian Nationalism, And The Presidential Election:
I suspect they’re hanging out in a dorm at Regent U., …soon to be rushed to a spare bedroom at the Virginia governor’s mansion (as soon as the anti-constitutionist new guv takes the oath.)
YES.Am a mom, this story has been especially hard to read about…
Please to teach mehow this typoing and grammar work with the English?
GAH. My cat could do better…
We’d LIKE to“see Eric Rudolph”! In bright orange attire and shackles would be nice…
The court needs to inflict a HUGE fine everyday that child is kept from it’s legal custodial parentSay $10,000.00 per day, then those “Christian” thugs who want to make this an EXAMPLE against lesbian parents will quit hiding the child.
include ANY organization as an accesory to kidnapping
beats the f*ck out of me…..hehehehe
I can’t help but wonderhow this situation would be different if Jenkins were the biological mother.
Nah….They’ll just pass around the collection plate a few more times and tell everyone that it’s what Jesus would want.
I hope they throw her sorry ass in jail for a long, long time.
Janet should begin a civil court case for pain and suffering from being denied her legal RightsNAIL that Lisa to the WALL, with mental distress damages in the 6-7 figure range.
Not just her.The members of the “Liberty” Council. Debbie Thurman. Anyone who’s helping her needs to get the maximum sentence.
AhhhhhhBut just remember, Pete… that just further fuels their Christian Martyr Syndrome and use it in the Reichministry for Propaganda to gain sympathy and money from the gullible.
they’ll still use it for faux martyrdomBUT they’ll f*ckin do it with 6-7 figures LESS!
Yup!I wholeheartedly agree with you, Pete… 1000%!
Also she should file a CRIMINAL CONTEMPT Not only against Lisa, but Lisa’s attorneys as it is known they worked with other right wing religious groups. It will be interesting to watch, as I had to prove my innocence of all the trumped up Bull Shit charges brought up by my ex. But in the court’s eyes I was guilty because I was Trans.
If I were Janet, I would name Tony Perkins as an accomplice to the hiding of Lisa and the child.
This is not just about criminal contemptAt this point, Miller is treading in the area of criminal law: custodial interference and/or kidnapping on the state level, and violations of the Parental Kidnapping Prevention Act on the federal level. She should be arrested and charged.
As for the lawyers, it depends on what they knew/know. Like many, I strongly suspect that Matt Staver and the others not only know her plans but helped her. On the other hand, I have had more than one client abscond with the kids without telling me anything. It’s a tricky situation.
Too late for an Amber Alert?Ms. Miller and child are probably safely in Uganda by now.
Is Christian right aiding and abetting Lisa Miller’s defianceRemember the Manhattan Declaration? Miller may be the first to openly adhere to the signatory Church’s declaration to committ civil disobedience. Remember defying a Judge’s order is contemptable and enforceable with criminal repercussions. Not to mention parental kidnapping. Miller is no longer the custodial parent and yet she is on the run with Isabella, the child. I question the Christian right participation and this can be found at Lisa Miller are christian groups aiding and abetting? http://lezgetreal.com/?p=24404
Civil disobedience or Moral disobedience?
In other words these Christians can’t play morality against morality. They took this poor lesbian to court in order to take her baby away from her and they lost to their own surprise. Now they want to claim a higher authority will allow them to defy the authority they thought to use to advance their own discrimination? That is certainly not something Jesus would do!
More proof:
Seriously, what part of what this woman is doing or has done sound like any of the tenants of her faith that directly have to do with her situation or those of her church and/or fellowship?
One more:
I men blame the Christians all you want–if you can call them that but you can hardly blame the Christianity. These are the actual words of Jesus I(in context!). So now you know exactly what Jesus would do!
I actually fear for Isabella’s safetyI wish I was kidding here, but I’m not. I believe Isabella is in grave danger. I’ve seen situations where parents kill their own children when they’re about to get ripped away in murder/suicide situations, especially when you wrap it up with religious BS.
OMG, here we go!I joined the Facebook group, and after a few days of posting opposing, rational arguments, I was booted off the group, but still able to post.
But now the whackjobs are really starting to come out of the sewers and gutters in a vain attempt to justify Miller’s actions.
I wonder if this might be prosecuted as a HATE CRIME?Those Christo-fascists claiming they’ll help keep the child from Janet are inflicting harm on her based on her orientation. You might not win the case, but you’d haul their a$$es into a court room, and make them lawyer up.
Robert P George should be watched like a hawkANY emails or calls which goes to the groups connected with Lisa. He is the Board chairman of National Organization for Marriage, and wrote the Manhattan proclaimation. He defines things as COMMON GOOD and NATURAL LAW to avoid the purely religious texts against homosexuality. This is one DANGEROUS f*cktard, and slippery as an eel. Tony Perkin’s network of klan families could hide Lisa and Isabel. Randall Terry’s folks would be worth watching too….they are NUKING FUTZ.
Since this custody battle has already gone into 2 statesAnd who knows which state or even other country Lisa may have gone to? The FBI should be investigating this kidnapping.