I’m truly honored to have received this appointment and am eager and excited about this opportunity that is before me. And at the same time, as one of the first transgender presidential appointees to the federal government, it demonstrates a commitment to hire the best qualified for a position and thus this appointment is symbolic of future opportunities for many others.
~Amanda Simpson
Brian Bond, speaking as the White House Office of Public Engagement (aka the LGBT liaison), recently answered a question regarding visibility and role models of trans-identified people in the Obama Administration, and whether a trans-identified person would be appointed to Obama Administration in the first round of appointments. His answer to the questions:
You will definitely see that in the first round…[The] appointments are an ongoing process, as you know, but I can stand here with both feet on the ground and tell you that it will be LGBT in the Obama Administration.
So, perhaps it should be no real bit of news that back in late November, Amanda Simpson facebooked this bit of news:
Amanda Simpson: I have accepted an appointment by the Obama Administration to take the position of Senior Technical Advisor to the Bureau of Industry and Security. I will be working directly with the Under Secretary of Commerce and though the BIS dealing with the intersection of international trade and national security.
Ms. Simpson begins her new job in the Obama Administration this coming Tuesday. She’s going to be a presidential appointee at the Department of Commerce’s Bureau of Industry and Security;
her job will encompass the managing exports of dual use technology, as well as press and media liaison work for the agency.
Politically, she’s been publicly involved as a Democrat for awhile. As an example, she ran as a Democrat for the Arizona House of Representatives back in 2004.
Amanda Simpson was the first transgender candidate I’d ever communicated with personally. We ended up emailing each other after I donated $35 to that 2004 campaign. Hey, as a then poor trans woman, $35 was a whole lot of money for me at the time — as I recall, it was the first political campaign I’d ever contributed to. I donated to her campaign not only because I liked her politics, but her candidacy and her life story were inspiring to me. And, for the record, she graciously treated me with respect and kindness in her emails when I was completely unknown with in the trans community, and definitely was an unknown person in the broader lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) community.
Ms. Simpson is highly qualified for this position at the Bureau of Industry and Security. Just from the technical side of things, she actually is a rocket scientist; she was a Deputy Director in the advanced programs organization at Raytheon Missile Systems. She also is an accomplished pilot — holding a Certified Flight Instructor’s License — as well as having worked as a test pilot for nearly 20 years.
Ms. Simpson wasn’t appointed to the Obama Administration because she’s transgender — the Obama Administration isn’t, for example, appointing horse stable managers to head departments like FEMA because they check the right political or demographic boxes. The Obama Administration has been looking for qualified people with the skill sets and character required to fill specific positions. Ms. Simpson was appointed because she has the right skill set for the job; she has the right character for the job; she’s actually the right person for the job. Her being transgender is a nice, checked box for those of us who track identity politics and diversity issues, but her appointment speaks more to how Ms. Simpson wasn’t disqualified from the position for which she is so highly qualified, simply for identifying as transgender.
I believe we can safely say Amanda Simpson’s appointment would not have been possible under the Bush Administration.
So, Amanda Simpson’s appointment says something wonderful about just how far trans-identified people have come in the past decade. Ms. Simpson is highest level appointee to a presidential administration in our country’s history; her appointment is actually historic.
As the mother of a young ten year old trans girl and the President of TransYouth Family Allies, Inc. (TYFA), Amanda’s appointment makes for a wonderful New Year’s gift. Parents encourage their daughters to be their best and strive to reach new heights, always mindful of the bias that some women receive in the work place. Parents of trans girls fear that the bias will be twofold for their daughters. Amanda has shattered that fear with her bravery and willingness to be in the public eye. Today begins a new era for trans women. I publicly applaud Amanda for her achievements, successes and her courage to be who she is. She has set a wonderful example for my daughter and for thousands of girls just like her.
~Shannon Garcia, President of TransYouth Family Allies, Inc.
I like the idea that Amanda Simpson, a trans-identified woman with an incredible resume, is becoming an inspirational figure for trans youth. Amanda Simpson’s appointment speaks to a new reality: The next generations of trans people can dream much bigger dreams than trans people in generations past.





29 Comments


You go girl!She broke the taffeta ceiling.
I know I make this same comment every time one of these appointments happens, butI think it bears repeating: This is genuinely great news for Amanda. But it doesn’t do a thing for the rest of us, whether we’re trans, gay/lesbian or what have you. Mistaking one individual’s new job for progress for our entire community is exactly the kind of misdirection I suspect politicians like to see us to get caught up in. Should we celebrate an appointment in the same way we’d celebrate a genuine advance in our equality?
Great for Amanda, another crumb for the rest of us (and barely that).
Oh, I disagreeThis is genuinely fantastic news for Amanda (who I know obliquely, through my involvement with Out & Equal Workplace Advocates), but it’s also something for the entire LGBT community to celebrate. A smaller victory for the community at large than for Ms. Simpson personally, but something to celebrate nonetheless.
I worked for a federal contractor when their first African-American was promoted to the partnership, earning the title of Vice-President. Retention among people of color that year was something like 14% greater for the entire company than the year before. I can’t claim that all of the people of color who might have left in an average year stuck around solely because this one individual was promoted, but it was such a significant increase that I don’t think it’s too far-fetched to assume that many folks who didn’t believe that they could “make it” at the company reevaluated this belief because someone in senior leadership finally looked like them. I also theorize that many of the white managers at the company looked at their direct reports a little differently. Suddenly, there were a lot more employees who “looked like” future leaders of the firm; it might just be that people stuck around not just because they found a new role model, but because they were personally treated like the talented individuals with genuine potential they were.
When people see a trans-identified person – particularly one as smart and talented as Amanda Simpson – take on a leadership role, it can have a real impact on the way that transgender women and men are perceived. To be sure, many people who hear about this appointment will continue to believe that Amanda is nothing more than a freak. But those in the “movable middle” might reconsider their automatic biases for just a moment, and ruminate on the fact that this woman (who was once male-identified) is smart and talented enough to earn a Presidential appointment to a role that has nothing to do with her identity as a transgender woman.
I don’t suggest that this one appointment will spark a domino effect that will guarantee full equality for all LGBT people, but I do believe that it’s just one of a series of small victories that will slowly but surely improve the lives of many of us. And that’s kind of cool.
It does mean thatwe have far greater rights if we have a government job than does most of the LGBT community
I think her appointmentrepresents progress already made by our community, and in that was is very significant. Has any out transperson been appointed by the Executive, ever? If they have, I’ll wager it has been unknowingly. What remains to be seen is whether the Obama Administration will stand by the appointment in the face of the fundie garment rending we know is to come. If it does, that too is another indication of progress. Sure her appointment doesn’t win any of us any more rights, and sure on its own it can be seen as tossing the mongrels a bone to keep us quiet, but I do think the appointment, if it sticks, helps to set a new, higher bar for visible LGBT inclusion. In that way it benefits us all.
isn’t that the caseregardless of whether this appointment was made?
Progress or Something ElseI look at everything we in the T community do that brings recognition in the public sphere as progress. Every positive media report means some transperson somewhere will have a little bit more hope for a better life.
I am constantly in awe of my email and regular mail bringing me comments and requests from around the world. Amanda must have the same. I enjoy responding to those I can or should, unfortunately I receive email from countries where transpeople are oppressed or killed. I am always in a quandry about responding because the censors will have another reason to do something bad to those people.
I am very happy for Amanda. My hope is that she will use her influence to do more than prove that transwomen are not a Barbi doll and “a guy in a dress” to those within the Beltway. I hope she helps bring more transpeople to the government employ so that many will learn about us and kick the ignorance out the door. I hope that she will use her abilities to bring many more transpeople to private employ.
Those of us in the public view must be the leaders, the ambassadors and the teachers to so many who know nothing or worse about transpeople.
Visible Role Models.I love the quote from Shannon Garcia. Hopes and dreams are what all childhoods should be about.
It is a step forward……albeit a small one. She’s obviously well-qualified and deserving, but I’d bet the fact that she’s trans definitely helped her case. I think it’s likely that it was seen as an opportunity for the Obama Administration to do something public and positive in regard to hiring transpeople after the Diane Schroer case made anti-trans discrimination a public issue.
And even if that’s all true, what really matters most is that a highly qualified transperson was appointed by the President to a high-level federal government position. That’s what really matters most and what will continue to matter once the dust settles and all the media attention goes away.
And no, it’s no substitute for what we really need from our government and our President, but at least it’s something.
A door has been opened here, and hopefully it’ll stay that way.
maybe she got the job because of her qualfications?congrats to the lady.
Congrats!Amanda’s one of the few people I know who are well qualified for this job. I don’t know how she finds the time for Trans activism too.
Yet another of the intelligent, talented women with an extraordinary track record despite their difficult situation who, once they get their somatic anomalies fixed, really start to achieve a truly stellar performance. Not just in one area, but many simultaneously.
I’m glad she was given the opportunity to shine. Let’s make sure others are too.
ENDA’s not just important for trans people – it’s important for the nation, to make sure that talents like hers are not wasted.
At the risk of sounding frivolous and OT,can I just say that that is a really beautiful picture?
You watch!The reicht will try to dig up something on Amanda other than the fact she “mutilated” herself to become an approximation of a woman…
Thank you Ronald Reagan for allowing these immoral perverts legitimacy and allowing them to crawl from the gutters and sewers and into the halls of power.
Well, it may not be just the religious right.One of the horrible things about being trans is taking guff from a small number of people who in some way identify as transsexual, or in the past could have been identified in some way by trans terminology, but don’t identify as transgender, as well as from a small number of LGB people.
So yes, I expect the worst from some conservative Christians on Amanda Simpson’s appointment to the BIS, but I also have come to expect the worse in others that perhaps should or could be natural allies as well. It speaks to how many trans people are perceived – trans people of all stripes are an oppressed lot, from they are oppressed and/or treated shabbily by people of many stripes.
Inspirational!It’s nice to see trans-women in technical fields rise to positions commensurate with our experience. As a trans-women in a technical field I am proud and inspired by her appointment. This means a lot to me, personally, whether or not people think this is “bread crumbs”. It has inspired me to try harder, to reach for my potential. Read: My next Cisco certification (CCNA R&S) exam next spring.
ZoeB pointed out that once we get our somatic differences sorted we go on to excel in our fields of expertise. I couldn’t agree more. Personally I have noticed this for myself having gotten the internal distractions dealt with. I have noticed my capacity to do more and better work has increased. I look forward to more opportunities in this new decade as a new woman.
Amanda has done more excelling in her field than she may realize for all of us behind the scenes techies. She’s a freaking hero to me. Good on you Amanda!!
Hooray for Amanda and hooray for all of us!!
And The Dems TooRemember that Barney Frank is more than willing to toss us under the wheels of progress.
I have as much a problem with my own party as I do with my opponents. Not all Dems are accepting!
Don’t spoil the moment!As far as I’m concerned Amanda should just concentrate on her job. There will always be people hating on us, but it should by no means stop us from our dreams. I like to fix things and I don’t think it makes you less of a woman.
I usually get trouble from older men who think women don’t know how to fix a printer the size of chest freezer. This one does and some old f*cktard is not going to stop me. It was a little intimidating at first, but once I got at it, it was kinda fun. I know I’m a hopeless case, I’m never getting out.
I repaired the monstrosity and got a new contract for doing so. I also complained to his boss, his bosses boss, and the client. His boss who gave him a talking to. They gave me more money after they couldn’t find anybody locally with the chops to take the job on when it broke again. I couldn’t even find a service guide for a line printer made in 1980. They really should upgrade.
The moral of the story is, do what you’re good at and don’t take any crap. You don’t get more work as a contractor (or anywhere else) by being meek.
Go do it anyway if somebody says you can’t do it. Because if you think you can’t you’re probably right.
Brava.This …
…is right on target.
And I just thought it bore repeating.
That is all.
And, that’s the take of my article. =)Seriously, the important thing here is the movement forward in how trans people are perceived in the workplace. Sure, this is just one hire and not ENDA, but it’s a hire that speaks to those slow, but significant changes in society.
I love the new reality is that the future generations of trans people will be — and are — dreaming bigger dreams for their lives than the dreams of past generations of trans people. Amanda Simpson dreamed big, and is paving a way for others to do the same.
Which would be indicative of even more progress…‘cuz that’s the ideal situation for EVERYONE!!!
And I have no doubt Amanda will ROCK her new job…
Well, then…The Obama Administration just thumbed its nose at Barney Frank’s prejudices!
Which could have seriously positive consequences for ENDA type bills!
I just can’t see it that way.If this administration had acted better toward us than it has, I’d certainly agree with you. But I simply can’t forget the history. All we have gotten from the Obama White House are words and token gestures meant to placate us–and NO ACTION at all. (After all, a lot of people were saying what you’re saying now when John Berry was appointed to head OPM–and look what that’s gotten us.) Until we get something meaningful from Obama, it’s impossible for me to see this appointment as anything other than tokenism (which is not to say Amanda doesn’t deserve it quite fully). And tokenism is not a victory.
I like the way you think, Karen.Who knows if what you’re saying is true, from this point forward, but I like to be optomistic about equality issues. =)
Well, it looks like the policy isn’t just lip serviceCongratulations to Amanda Simpson for breaking the barrier. Having had so much in the way of lip service from the Obama Administration, it is refreshing to know that the administration actually means what it says about not discriminating against qualified trans applicants.
Then again, like any other woman, she probably had to be at least twice as qualified . . .
Being one of over 300,000 applicants for one of the 75,000 federal plum jobs, I never heard a word about my own application, which was spurred as a test of the executive order. I am glad that there is someone who has gotten through the process to show that the policy is for real.
The MSM…has not had one article about Ms. Simpson appointment. So far it seems to be only in the blogshere or the LGBT media and everyone is quoting the NTCE press release.
I haven’t yet figured out of it is good or bad that this hasn’t hit the MSM radar yet.
I sent the story to Rachel Maddow……because I figured if anyone in the MSM might be interested it would be her. Got my fingers crossed, but I’ve yet to see Rachel properly cover, or really even directly mention, transgender people on her show, not even when a story (such as the passage of the hate crimes bill) would seem to call for it.
Still, I’ll keep sending her stuff…hopefully someday she’ll cover us.
Its on the CNN political ticker
As when I’m writing this……the Wahsington Times, AirAmerica, CNN, ABC, the Virginian-Pilot, and Examiner.com have all picked the story of Amanda Simpson’s appointment.
Oh, and for LGBT press of note……On Top Magazine, Bay Windows, and 365Gay have also picked up on the story.