Wow, I didn’t think they would really try to lodge the claim that there’s a religious denomination gene that ensures your faith is predetermined when you shoot out of the womb, but when you’re an anti-gay Republican like House Minority Leader John Boehner (R-OH) , it’s ok to send your spokesperson out there to look like a complete jackass.
Questioned about why the House’s top Republican opposes a hate crimes bill penalizing violence against gays, his spokesman said he “supports existing federal protections (based on race, religion, gender, etc) based on immutable characteristics,” just not protections for things like being gay — which conservatives occasionally claim is a choice.
When CBSNews.com asked Boehner’s office to comment, it’s quite clear that the Ohio Congressman and his mouthpiece are completely ignorant about the law that is currently in place, since gender is not included. Boehner spokesman Kevin Smith was ridiculed for this religion-is-in-the-DNA logic for opposing adding sexual orientation and gender identity into the law.
Northeastern University professor Jack Levin, who co-authored the first book written about hate crimes, told Hotsheet that “to use immutability as a criterion doesn’t make any sense at all.”
“Especially if he supports the current stand,” Levin continued. “Religion is clearly not ascribed. It’s not built into the organism. People can change it at any time and people do.”



14 Comments





I am sure it makes perfect sense to themGod makes us in his image and he’s Christian (isn’t he?).
Wait, who makes the Jews, Muslims, Hindis..,
I suspect they saw thison The Onion News Network and didn’t catch on fully…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v…
But of course
Well what would you expect from Silent Bob? Jay would have made much more sense.
And sadly, even though I was snarkily joking above, that last part’s probably true.
“Snooch to the nooch”
“Religion is immutable”
One of those is pure nonsense. The other is a line delivered by Jason Mewes in several movies.
But seriously…
I’m beginning to wonder if this moronic convergence is something that has skidded along unscathed through this discourse because everyone on both sides has ignored it – the Boner-oids because its their BS talking point and people on the side of reality because we’re so used to their really big lies (gay = pedophile, trans woman = rapist, etc.) that we miss this one, which is usually delivered via throwaway line.
It almost never fails that some christianist will give the ‘civil rights are for immutable characteristics’ line in defense of a civil rights status quo that includes religion – and it almost never fails that no one follows up to call them out one it.
If religion isn’t a choicethen why are they funneling obscene sums of money into their ministries to convert people?
disconnectThe Antis will say anything and do.
Are tanning beds cooking his brain?He’s begining to make Michelle Bachman not the stupidest thing on two legs.
Or the non-religious?We atheists must all be in denial or something.
Surprised there hasn’t been a follow-up proposing that atheism be considered a mental illness…
How do I changefrom being a 6’2″ butch?
I know I got the best there was as to the mindf*@k they call ex-gay ‘therapy’.
Please explain it to me I am all ears.
I’m not the sick one.
and yetthey still try to convert non-Gentiles when they think religion is genetic? jeez
If Religion is Genetic…Can we find a vaccine?
I wrote a letterto my House Rep (Randy Forbes (R-Va)) about a week ago asking that he help get ENDA passed this year and I got an almost identical response…
In my letter I stated:
His response included:
Notice his mis-representation of gender already being included and the fact that he includes religion as ‘sufficient coverage’ because it’s not a “person’s lifestyle or behavior”.
I can play their gameDear friends, there is a way to pull away from the hate and confusion of the unhealthy “christian” lifestyle.
Give your soul over to REALITY
Take that, GOPConservatives will say anything that the think their flock can memorize and pass along at the town hall. It’s got to be catchy! And this is catchy.
For a look at the GOP marketing strategy, watch:
http://bit.ly/fxv3G
(satire)
I guess Religion is not a Choice if you have been brainwashed in itsince the age of 2. That is precisely the tack we ought to take with these people. OK, you have had this fallacious, sex-obsessed, body-controlling, overbearingly paternalistic, religion shoved down your throat for 18 years while you were subject to your parents wishes. Now that you are an adult, what is your excuse?