Talk about health care ironies. I was sick as a dog this AM, due to side effects from my meds, and didn't bother to check one of my email accounts today. I was invited to a blogger conference call featuring President Obama, David Axelrod, Nancy Anne DeParle and the White House online liaison, Jesse Lee. I'd kick myself, except what can you do when the room is spinning and your vision is blurry and can do little more than lie in the bed.
Anyway, instead of crying over a missed opportunity, it's good that fellow invitees did check their email, attend the call and over at Crooks & Liars, John Amato has the full audio of the call. He also has a recap of the Q&A (once there's a transcript, I'll post it); he noted that the President “is pleased that bloggers have been letting Congress know all about the desperation Americans are feeling and that's been critical, and he wants us to keep up the pressure on Congress and the media.” and Sam Stein of Huff Post has a good write up. Sam:
In a roughly 25-minute session with a handful of prominent progressive bloggers, the president also asked for help combating disinformation about his health care plan.
“I know the blogs are best at debunking myths that can slip through a lot of the traditional media outlets,” he said. “And that is why you are going to play such an important role in our success in the weeks to come.”
The call demonstrates just how heated the health care debate has become in recent weeks and how much ammunition the administration is willing to bring to the table. At various points in the call, the president offered a strikingly detailed synopsis of his political strategy and health care policy as a whole.
While he refused to insist that lawmakers stay in Washington during the August recess, he declared definitively that, “the time for talk is through.”
“Now is the time for us to go ahead and act,” Obama declared. “We are working as hard as we can and I have told Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi that it is critical that we have seen serious forward motion before people leave [in August].”
Moreover, for the first time in recent memory, Obama floated the possibility that if it appears that health care reform lacks the 60 votes needed for passage, he might be open to reconciliation, which would allow for an up-or-down vote on budgetary and tax aspects of the bill.
I'm glad the administration acknowledged the role that bloggers can play in moving the health care debate forward, enough so to actually convene a conference call to discuss policy development.
I think you know what my next question is — why is it that bloggers who focus on LGBT issues don't merit that level of engagement on those issues? Some of those invited to this health care call also blog LGBT issues, but it's clear that we don't exist in that capacity to the administration. I guess our existence and purpose is limited to the issues they believe in. We are seen as essential – when they desperately need cheerleaders at the grassroots level on the right issues.
Remember, throughout the brouhahas about the Stonewall event and relentless dodging on DADT, DOMA, etc., no LGBT bloggers were invited to the event. There were no conference calls of the sort that was held on health care today. Clearly I wasn't waiting by my inbox or phone anyway since: 1) I've been critical of the admin on progress re: LGBT issues and questions went unanswered; and 2) I figured since I'm living in Nowhereville, USA, and have no connections to Big Gay Orgs, they don't believe what I (or what you, the readers) think is relevant to any LGBT policy discussions. On this subject it's a closed communication circle that includes org heads and Beltway LGBTs of interest, not bloggers.
However, apparently as a progressive blogger I do matter to this White House when it is an “all hands on deck” moment — they want the right wing myths, lies and propaganda about the Obama health care reform proposal debunked. And I will – the fact is that I do have a vested interest in fixing the system (see my post “Health care in the U.S. – stop bickering and fix it“), since I'm a frequent user of the health care services. The White House is right to court the grassroots to mobilize actions to put pressure on the members of Congress who are queasy on reform; we need every vote.
However, I just thought I'd point out that big elephant in the room about the inconsistency in how the White House views bloggers. I haven't seen anyone else mention that irony in the blogging so far about the call today.
***
UPDATE: A couple of other nuggets, here from Joe@Americablog:
Before he left, the President mentioned his criteria for reform: Does it cover all Americans; Will it drive down costs over the long-term; Will it improve quality; Are prevention and wellness included; Does it contain insurance reforms on issues like pre-existing conditions; does it provide relief to small business; and, is there a serious public option. He warned that the different bills coming from the House and Senate may not have all of those provisions, but the conference committee will be critical.
Also, Michael “MC” Steele weighed in, as only he can do as head of the RNC, in a simplistic, weary fashion that doesn't offer anything as an alternative to what's broken in our current system. Read the press release below the fold.
From the release that hit my inbox from the RNC:
Republican National Committee (RNC) Chairman Michael Steele today announced a new television ad opposing President Obama’s plan for a government-run health care system during a speech at the National Press Club.The ad, entitled “Grand Experiment,” can be viewed here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PRqQASW3RCY. Starting today, this large, targeted television ad campaign will run in select markets in Arkansas, Nevada and North Dakota. “Once again President Obama and Congressional Democrats are rushing through a grand experiment that will have serious consequences for future generations of Americans. It started with their failed stimulus bill and has now moved on to a trillion-dollar government-run health care plan that is simply wrong for America. Republicans know we need health care reform – costs are too high and families are struggling to afford quality care. But the Democrats’ plan would raise taxes on small businesses and lead to higher costs and rationed care,” said Chairman Michael Steele.
You notice it's all criticism and no alternative plan? What is the Republican plan — a tax credit? What if you have no job, no insurance and your kid has a chronic disease? A tax break to buy private insurace is no solution, so what does the party of family values do for that family? What is transparent is the goal of the Republicans, and it's not your health care — it's toppling Obama and the Dems. To hell with reform that affects
every last person in this country — everything is about being partisan.
The GOP ad is ridiculous.
Voice: “They’ve loaned Barack Obama their future, without even knowing it.”
Voice: “Trillions for rushed government bailouts and takeovers, banks, the auto industry.”
Chyron: Trillions for government bailouts and takeovers
Voice: “The biggest spending spree in our nation's history.”
Chyron: The biggest spending spree in history
Voice: “And they'll have to pay.”
Voice: “The next big ticket item? A risky experiment with our health care.”
Chyron: A risky experiment with health care
Voice: “Barack Obama’s massive spending experiment hasn’t healed our economy.”
Chyron: Barack Obama’s massive spending experiment
Voice: “His new experiment risks their future and our health.”
Chyron: BarackObamaExperiment.com
Chyron: Risking everything.
Voice: “The Republican National Committee is responsible for the content of this advertising.”ONSCREEN Disclaimer: The Republican National Committee is responsible for the content of this advertising. Paid for by the Republican National Committee. Not authorized by any candidate or candidate’s committee. www.gop.com
Now tell me, how many things listed in the above fear-mongering commercial already applies to the current system? We spend more on health care than other industrialized nations per person. And as far as “massive spending experiment” goes, my jaw hit the table — no one can top the massive spending experiment called Dear Leader's Big Adventure into Iraq that we continue to pay dearly for. Unbelievable.



10 Comments



Sheesh PamI can’t believe you dissed the Prez. LOL!
Hope you feel better soon.
As far as I know,there were no single payer advocates on the call, right? To make an analogy, it’s kind of like Obama having a call with “progressive” GLBT rights bloggers who were fine with civil unions.
I am sure there will be a next timeWith the party of “NO” on high alert, I am sure there will be more conference calls with progressive bloggers. I anticipate another blogger conference later this year when immigration reform is brought to the table. It will be interesting to see if the UAFA is included in immigration reform and if LGBT bloggers will be invited to the conference call.
Get Well Soon, Pam.
the reason they don’t engage the blogosphere on LGBT issuesis that the conversation is too often dominated by inflammatory and inaccurate stuff like you find at Americablog.
Steele CurtainSorry, but since the GOP revealed itself as a party built on lies–with a catastrophic economic model based on lies, loans to liars and bigger loans to bigger liars; with a war that continues to hemorrhage, based on lies; with a parade of family values clowns who are demonstrated to be liars—why in the name of anything that is rational should there be any credence paid to the buffoon that is leading that band?
The question of LGBT issuesis dubious at best. Its been quite obvious that this administration has had other issues at the top of its agenda. As I’ve said before, they are focusing their energy on their top priorities right now. Its tough for some people to accept, but the reality is that with something this important to the entire nation in the balance, the LGBT issues would need to wait.
Right now they need all progressive hands focused on fighting for health care.
Other issues are at the top, middle and bottomof the Democratic Agenda. I am not Kansas. The sooner the Democratic Party figures out that I am not going to abandon the party if they actually deliver on civil rights, the better for everyone. Minimalist incrementalism is far more likely to turn me off than actually standing on a moral position.
Too bad all progressive handsare not being progressive. Too many of them (at least the A list toadies who participated on the call) are supporting Obama’s massive giveaway to the for-profit insurance compaies, instead of pushing for liberal health care reform.
Single payer or some such structure has been adopted in most other industrialized countries, and is the major reason why those countries not only provide health care for all of their citizens, but do so at a rate of less than half of the rate that is the case in this country. And Obama is pushing a bill that props up our current failed system.
If such “progressives” are supporting the center-right Obama on this failed bill, why do you think that center-right Obama, or these “progressives” would support LGBT issues anytime?
Transcripts at Show Me ProgressPresident Obama: health care reform – blogger conference call
President Obama: health care reform – blogger conference call – Q and A
Still working on the remainder…
Health Insurance is a product you purchase, not a right provided to you by a government entityHi Pam,
I’ve been a daily reader/scanner of your blog for a few months now and am just signing up. I will confess I have found many things I disagree with you in some of your posts. This one particularly caught my attention.
Please tell me that you really DO know why you/other LGBT focused bloggers weren’t invited to the conference call. If you don’t, then I hope I can enlighten you. You’re not needed or wanted by the POTUS; right now.
“However, apparently as a progressive blogger I do matter to this White House when it is an “all hands on deck” moment — they want the right wing myths, lies and propaganda about the Obama health care reform proposal debunked. And I will – the fact is that I do have a vested interest in fixing the system (see my post “Health care in the U.S. – stop bickering and fix it”), since I’m a frequent user of the health care services.” - You are on target here, but still slightly to the left. Pardon the pun.
The left is putting out “myths, lies and propaganda”, too, mind you. There are always two sides of the lies coming from Washington. The biggest one on both sides that I can’t get past is the constitutionality of any kind of mandatory Federal Government provided health care. I can’t believe that Congress and most of the disinformed American public thinks the constitution allows Congress to pass any legislation that takes money from me to pay for health care for my neighbor.
Health care is not a right that the federal government provides to us, or should provide for us. It is a product that everyone needs for their own well being and should work to provide for themselves. We have programs for those who can’t; my mother is a recipient of STATE health care.
If you believe the constitution allows Congress to pass this type of legislation due to the “general welfare” clause, then you don’t understand that the constitution strictly forbids Congress from taking money disproportionately from “We the People”. Even if there were a way to make everyone pay the same amount for the same type of coverage, the constitution still doesn’t allow Congress to pass this type of legislation.
America is a Republic. ”…and to the Republic for which it stands…” It is NOT a Democracy. Or, I should say it is NOT supposed to be a Democracy. More government programs/spending is the problem, not the solution.
Do you actually think that more federal government programs will help America’s health care problems? Ask any local Doctor at Duke and I’m sure they will tell you that the current government regulations and insurance regulations are the problems. Adding more will only worsen it. Not too mention, we just don’t have the money/credit to pay for it.
We need less government intrusions and let the free market do its job. Has America completely given up on the free market in favor of government intrusion and ownership?
Here are a few suggestions to help the health care system without government intervention/ownership. (Thanks Will!)
1 Deregulating the healthcare industry to improve efficiency and choices
2 Allowing consumers to buy only the coverage they desire (many states require insurance providers to provide certain items in any policy they sell)
3 Reducing the number of government mandates and red tape that drives up medical costs
4 Removing barriers to safe, affordable medicines (let informed consumers buy drugs that have been approved overseas; in one example, the FDA delayed approving one heart medication for 10-years when this could have saved 100,000 lives during that time)
5 Increasing access to imported, lower-cost medications
6 Deregulating many medications removing the need/expense for doctor’s consultations to get a prescription
7 Allowing health/insurance providers to offer their products nation-wide rather than on a state-by-state basis to increase options and competition
8 Allowing healthcare “freedom of choice” and leave the treatment decision between a doctor and patient
9 Disallowing abuse of our healthcare system by those here illegally
10 Cutting taxes and entitlement programs significantly to allow citizens to obtain affordable healthcare options best suited for their needs
11 Allowing private-sector and charitable organizations with expertise in the matter to lead medical research initiatives; let the government focus on its congressionally-mandated duties
12 Discouraging frivolous lawsuits driving up medical costs
13 Encouraging Medical Savings Accounts
14 Reducing certain taxes imposed on medical services to cut the overall health care costs
15 Allowing citizens to be uninsured
If you haven’t seen this blog, may I suggest you read a few of the posts and become a daily scanner? http://theblacksphere.net/site…
Other suggested reading/viewing.
http://64.203.107.114/alexande…
http://www.silverbearcafe.com/…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v…