NOTE FROM PAM: Former Co-Chair of the Obama LGBT Leadership Council during the 2008 campaign, Stampp Corbin, contributed this essay on discrimination that is spot on — it discusses the numerous subtle ways that we are “othered” every day in a heterocentric society that have a great impact on our lives.
Counting all forms of discrimination against LGBTs
by Stampp CorbinThe original definition of the word discrimination was a harmless one. It’s meant to have the ability to detect fine distinctions, like a wine connoisseur can detect citrus and oak in different bottles of chardonnay. Today the word discrimination is used to describe treatment based upon a class or category, rather than individual merit or simply put, prejudice. Discrimination comes in all forms, from the overt to the subtle.
When it comes to the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender community, discrimination against us is often some of the most subtle. Much of it is so subtle; most Americans don’t even know it exists. How are members of the LGBT community discriminated against? Let me count the ways.
First, there is our inability to be open and honest about our relationships at work. Whether it is in the military or at the local family restaurant, some in the LGBT community are closeted at work because they can be fired in many states just for being a member of the LGBT community. Yet, our straight co-workers can extol their divorces and third marriage to reckless abandon. A gay man talking about his 12 year relationship with his partner, not good.
Let me count the ways. In some states where gays and lesbians have domestic partnership or civil union health care benefits, those benefits are taxed as ordinary income. That means a gay spouse pays $1,000 to the government for the same $3,000 worth of benefits that are given to a straight spouse with no taxation. When it comes to the military, “traditional” families are given many benefits when their loved one is deployed. LGBT families get none of these benefits. In fact, many LGBT partners are informed of their loved one’s death not by the military, but by the soldier’s family. Thanks for making the ultimate sacrifice. We would have kicked you out anyway had we known you were gay or lesbian.
Let me count the ways. If my brother and I were killed in an automobile accident and my brother left an estate of $1 million, his wife would receive his entire estate tax free. My partner Scott would be forced to pay an estate tax of about 30 percent because the federal government does not consider us related. So Scott pays $300,000 to Uncle Sam, my brother’s wife would pay nothing. That is discriminatory.
When it comes to social security, my sister-in-law would be the beneficiary of my brother’s social security, my partner Scott would get absolutely nothing. So the LGBT community is contributing to the stability of the social security system by letting all the money we have contributed go back into the system at our death, instead of to our loved ones. Sound fair to you?
Then there are those pesky hospital situations. Scott and I had to hire an attorney to ensure that he has the power to make medical decisions for me. No problem for my sister-in-law, this ability is automatic with her marriage certificate. What’s worse is my sister-in-law simply has to state to the doctor or nurse, “I am his wife.” No asking for proof, it is accepted. Scott says “I am his partner,” the response often is “Do you have a living will stating so, and do you have a copy for our records?” Isn’t discrimination grand?
Let me count the ways. How about the member of the LGBT community that falls in love with someone from another country. Does their partner get to immigrate to the U.S.? Absolutely not. A straight couple, the spouse is welcomed with open arms. In fact, mail order brides still exist and they get automatic citizenship. LGBT partners, get in line; you may get citizenship in seven to ten years. All men are created equal…except lesbians, gays, bisexuals and transgender.
So now you know. The LGBT community is discriminated against in everyday life. There are over 1,100 rights that married couples get from the federal government that Scott and I are denied. So what are you going to do about it? Are you going to be part of the problem or the solution?



Counting all forms of discrimination against LGBTs
19 Comments



This is very helpfulOpponents of gay marriage dismiss the impact on gays not being able to marry. Just the rights lost enumerated here are enough to show why gay marriage should be the law of the land. I would love to know if the over 1100 rights married couples get that are denied gay couples are enumerated somewhere. If I’m going to use that number when talking to people, I’d love to have a source or citation to point to…
is this a hearts/minds moment?I’m wondering if this piece from Mr. Corbin would qualify as an example of “in your face” activism or is an attempt to “change hearts and minds” about discrimination?
These arguments have been made many times in various places.
Should they be made in face to face exchanges during a door knocking campaign or would they be far too confrontational?
What I heard at the repeal prop 8 meeting the other night makes it sound like we don’t need to address these points directly to our oppressors and should either share a drink and a scallop wrapped in bacon or engage in a square dance instead.
Passive aggressive requests for social justice is not the same thing as civil disobedience.
Good examplesThese are examples of discrimination that should resonate with people. And, in my experience, a lot of people don’t know these things. Even a lot of LGBT people don’t know these things!
I do want to mention, though, that mail order brides (or anyone marrying a different-sex US citizen) do not get automatic citizenship. They get a green card. I’m pretty sure no one gets citizenship just through marriage. They’d still have to go through the waiting period and class if they chose to become a citizen, right?
Thank you!I think this is an excellent summation of several distinct discriminatory issues towards LGBT Americans. Often I hear opponents of equality say “All you have to do is get an attorney; it’s easy.” This article shows multiple instances where that is not applicable. Thanks for the information. I will be sharing it.
mail order brides…or any non US born half of a hetero binational couple doesn’t get auto citizenship but as soon as you become a fiancee of an American you can get your visa sponsored and then the process of becoming a citizen begins (you sponsor the permanent visa, get a green card, then US citizenship after 2 years and a test)…i think the major point is that we can’t even sponsor the visa so the rest is irrelevant even when we’ve been in a relationship for years…wish i didn’t know the bittersweet way, but silly me falling for a guatemalan girl..
Yes, this is well done and should be widely publicizedIt’s not surprising that straight people do not realize how much their heterosexual privilege benefits them…
But this piece by Stampp is exactly the kind of work that we need to do, and take the time to distribute to enough people so that California becomes a state where a STRONG majority supports ending all forms of discrimination against LGBT citizens.
Great pieceCan you even imagine the uproar if a married heterosexual whose spouse was in a terrible accident or had a stroke or some other kind of ER/ICU event had to actually leave the hospital campus to go find a copy of their marriage certificate before they were allowed to see their critically injured/dying spouse? That’s the sort of thing I wouldn’t wish on my worst enemy even if I had one. If your loved one dies, you don’t recover from that kind of thing, it haunts you for the rest of your life.
At least he was smart enough…to avoid comparing the LGBT rights to the black struggle for civil Rights
http://www.cnn.com/2009/POLITI…
BaffledIt baffles me that we do not approach this issue in a REAL way. Whadda I mean?
“Whatsoever you do” appeals to many christians and Christians, so let’s be real. Take our HORRIFIC stories, where our lack if rights led to suffering most people cannot imagine in their lifetime. Now let’s switch characters and have MR/MRS. HET be in our shoes. Or Barack and Michelle. Or Joe and Jill Biden.
OH NO! Suddenly it is a HORRIBLE, HORRIBLE thing to imagine. Barack held back from seeing Michelle as she was dying in the hospital?! Hillary Clinton being kicked out of her home after her husband dies?! Would Joe actually PAY MORE and tolerate discrimination?!
WE NEED TO GET REAL.
SPREAD THESE STORIES -
http://gaytaxprotest.blogspot….
I am certain that if every LGBTQ person experienced this kind of discrimination and the nightmares it can create, we’d be doing SO MUCH MORE than just donating money and acting as if we don’t have every right to revolt in the greatest way possible.
government documentationhttp://www.gao.gov/new.items/d…
http://www.gao.gov/archive/199…
What Would an All-American Man Do?My partner Scott would be forced to pay an estate tax of about 30 percent because the federal government does not consider us related. So Scott pays $300,000 to Uncle Sam, my brother’s wife would pay nothing. That is discriminatory.
I’m a simple-living guy whose head gets dizzy with the big money numbers there, and I hate to get all testosteroney here, but seriously:
Would an All-American He-Man pay $300,000 to the feds knowing it was pure discrimination? I seriously doubt it.
Why are we different? Just questions here. And I’m really not talking about muscles and brute strength, I’m talking about an AGGRESSIVE, CONFIDENT, ENTITLED ATTITUDE that doesn’t cower so easily in the face of the government.
“Acting” as if we really do deserve it!
I cannot understand why so many, esp. those with big money, submit to such gross injustices, esp. in a country where money is everything. I guess one point is that if people REALLY UNDERSTOOD our suffering, I think they’d get why we have such a valid reason for being MAD AS HELL and REVOLTING.
Exactly…….The question is, why aren’t LGBT organizations already doing this?
There’s a slight technicality thereThe recipient doesn’t pay the $300,000. It is removed from the estate before the transfer of wealth.
It might have something to do with…The big money folks and the leaders of “the struggle” are not struggling.
The people on the bottom won’t get hit with this precisely because they do not have sufficient assets for this to ever be an issue (never mind having other things to worry about).
This is not a unified community with a unified sense of purpose. Unlike most minority movements that were usually getting screwed across the board and pretty much all living difficult lives, the gay community is just not that homogenous. We are not all impacted equally by government policies. You find the same sort of stratification in the women’s movement.
Plan AheadI know, I know…….but if I had that kind of money, I would be finding every possible way to break the law and hide the cash, since government literally forces us to break the law if we are to maintain our dignity and freedom.
Making Love used to be illegal until 2003.
It seems kissing in public is illegal in some parts.
Being honest on government forms is illegal.
FUCK GOVERNMENT. They are overtly ABUSING US in every possible way.
Of course, I’ve been driven to “Old School” American thinking, where you fight for freedom, with arms if needed to defend one’s equality and economic freedom (freedom from being over-taxed and taxed unfairly).
No Kidding!I keep calling for SUFFERING EQUALITY – where we make sure everyone experiences the same suffering….gays and straights.
Both HETS and RICH GAYS would have a huge wake-up call if discrimination turned their wonderfully successful lives upside down and they ended up on disabilty and/or welfare.
Suddenly the discrimination becomes VERY REAL.
Suddenly grabbing a gun and defending one’s right to exist without further abuse from government doesn’t sound as “crazy” as it may….
I KNOW!This drove me nuts during the PROP 8 crap, because I had just speant 2 years re-building my life after a lack of rights wrecked havoc.
To see everyone discuss rights as a “concept” and not “that which prevents horrible suffering” was infuriating. I did not see or hear ANY mention in the NO ON PROP 8 Camp of the stories that I was posting on my blog (and they are all pretty well-known in gay-blog land). And my blog is as obscure as any.
No one addressed WHY rights are needed.
And the public still saw us whining about wanting a white dress and pretty flowers at the ceremony.
I give up on our “fight”. It will be a slow crawl until individuals stand up to government directly.
Looks like I’m going to have to be part of the problemIf you are going to say “transgender”, then, by f-ing G-d, you had better talk about transgender issues as well.
And, oddly enough, as usual, The Unesteemed Mr. Corbin has once again claimed to be speaking to their issues and then sorta forgot to provide any trans example.
Typical for a former member of the HRC.
When people in his position speak about othering, and then other me, well…
Just shows how uneducated and ignorant he is.
So expectedYnsaen:
Your comment illustrates your lack of tact. You do not know me and I do not know you, so keep your school girl or boy attacks to yourself. If you want to have a real discussion, try engaging without creating an environment where no one wants to respond.